Fantasy vs. Physics

The Economics of Green Energy Ideology

Gwyn Morgan
October 24, 2020
Solar panels filling fields in cloudy northern countries. Wind turbines manufactured for export by the world’s largest builder of coal-fired power and worst emitter of greenhouse gases. Governments deliberately demolishing their country’s most valuable industry. It is increasingly clear that so-called green energy isn’t just another instance of youthful idealism going a little too far, much less a practical way to a clean future, but a nasty utopian ideology bent on impoverishing entire countries. Gwyn Morgan examines a slice of this destructive landscape and warns of the severe risk to Canada’s economic well-being.
Fantasy vs. Physics

The Economics of Green Energy Ideology

Gwyn Morgan
October 24, 2020
Solar panels filling fields in cloudy northern countries. Wind turbines manufactured for export by the world’s largest builder of coal-fired power and worst emitter of greenhouse gases. Governments deliberately demolishing their country’s most valuable industry. It is increasingly clear that so-called green energy isn’t just another instance of youthful idealism going a little too far, much less a practical way to a clean future, but a nasty utopian ideology bent on impoverishing entire countries. Gwyn Morgan examines a slice of this destructive landscape and warns of the severe risk to Canada’s economic well-being.
Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter

Wildfires along the U.S. Pacific Coast, two simultaneous hurricanes in the Gulf of Mexico, melting glaciers and peat-bog fires in Canada, and an unusually hot summer in Europe together have raised global warming fears to frenzied proportions. Environmentalists are urging political leaders to legislate the rapid phase-out of fossil fuels. The most extreme call for action came from the future King of England, Prince Charles, who urged a “warlike footing” that would include creation of a centralized global authority to save the planet from catastrophic climate change. Just how such an unelected regime would exert power over the Earth’s 7.8 billion inhabitants wasn’t made clear.

The economics of green energy by c2c journal
economics of green energy c2c journal prince charles
A call to “war”: In the wake of some wild weather, Prince Charles advocates for global war-like measures to combat the changes.

The California and Oregon wildfires turned into an election issue, with Democratic Presidential candidate and former Vice President Joe Biden pointing to President Donald Trump’s pro-oil-industry policies as a cause. In fact, American greenhouse gas emissions have fallen by more than 14 percent since 2005, suggesting there’s very little connection between one country’s carbon dioxide emissions and global warming. Meanwhile, led by China and India, Asian emissions have doubled over the past decade and continue to grow. Overall, less than one-third of global emissions come from Western developed countries. China, India, Vietnam, South Africa, South Korea, the Philippines and Japan, all signatories to the Paris Climate Accord, are in various stages of constructing a mind-bending total of 1,800 coal-fired power plants.

The Economics of Green Energy by C2C Journal - Joe Biden turns a blind eye to real global emissions problems in china
Democratic Presidential candidate Joe Biden turns a blind eye to the real global emissions problem – China and its Communist dictatorship.

And that brings us to Canada. If our country were to disappear from the face of the Earth, those new plants would replace our 1.6 percent of global emissions in just a few months. Despite that reality, the Trudeau government is actually accelerating its ideologically driven program to replace fossil fuels with so-called green energy – mainly wind and solar. The government’s Throne Speech in late September virtually ignored the economic destitution its anti-oil policies have wrought in Alberta. Even the potential global market access provided through the expansion of the Trans Mountain Pipeline that is now underway was couched in terms of providing a bridge to a fossil-fuel-free paradise. 

The green energy fixation was also the focus of the Globe and Mail’s September 26 “Climate Issue”.

Columnist David Berman asserted that the costs of wind and solar power have “become attractive next to fossil fuels generating assets, particularly coal.” As evidence, he cited Tucson Electric Power’s phase-out of its coal-fired electricity generation. This is misleading.

The Economics of Green Energy by C2C Journal - construction equipment
The Economics of Green Energy by C2C Journal - Protest by environmentalists
Pipelines and hydro dams are both on environmentalists’ target lists, yet hydro gets counted under “renewable” energy when it suits them.

Data from the U.S. Energy Information Administration shows that coal-fired plants are indeed being phased out – but their output is being replaced by natural gas. In fact, wind and solar provide less than 1 percent of Arizona’s electricity requirements. The technical revolution in natural gas production of the past dozen or so years (popularly summed up as “shale gas” and “fracking”) has kept gas prices down even as production has soared.

Fellow Globe and Mail columnist Eric Reguly stated that Canada’s share of renewables – i.e., hydro, wind, biomass, solar and ethanol – is above the average for OECD countries. But as is often the case with selective-fact statements from green power advocates, Reguly failed to mention that the large majority of that comes from hydro power. Hydro power is in fact one of the oldest ways to generate electricity and has nothing at all to do with the green energy “revolution”. Further, the dams and reservoirs associated with large-scale hydropower are hated by most environmentalists, who are doing all they can to prevent construction of new dams and even to have existing dams dismantled. Wind and solar, meanwhile, made up just 2.3 percent of Canada’s electricity supply in 2019.

Vision for Canada? In Germany, thousands of these monsters clutter the landscape while generating immaterial “green” energy.

Looking globally, the widely respected BP World Energy Outlook 2019 shows that, despite many hundreds of billions of dollars invested, wind and solar contributed the same 2 percent of world energy supplies last year while the contribution of fossil fuels had actually increased to 84 percent. Germans have come to know and rue the hazards of pursuing a green power utopia all-too well. A decade-long attempt to replace coal and nuclear with wind and solar sent electricity costs soaring to the second-highest in the European Union. Despite hundreds of billions of euros invested, the basic unreliability of wind and solar necessitated Germany rehabilitating coal-fired power plants. In an ironic twist, the coal is sourced from the U.S., made readily available by the aforementioned conversion of America’s power generation to natural gas. 

In Ontario, the previous Liberal government led by former Premier Dalton McGuinty implemented a similar green power plan to that of Germany, with equally disastrous results. Coal-fired power plants were shuttered and planned expansion of nuclear plants cancelled. The government signed 25-year locked-in windmill and solar contracts at several times existing electricity rates. Electricity prices more than doubled, taking Ontario from one of North America’s lowest-cost power jurisdictions to among the highest, more than twice as high as other provinces. As beleaguered homeowners struggled to pay their electricity bills, manufacturers decamped to low-cost U.S. states like Georgia and the Carolinas. Caterpillar, United Steel, Heinz, General Motors, Navistar, Kellogg’s, John Deere, Kraft Foods, Unilever and Bacardi’s closed some or all of their Ontario plants. Ontario’s deep economic wound was entirely self-inflicted.

The Economics of Green Energy by C2C Journal
The Economics of Green Energy by C2C Journal
Just two of many big business closures after Ontario’s bad green energy policy (Kellogg’s plant in London, Ontario and abandoned Unilever soap factory in Toronto below). Above, Dalton McGuinty, the former Liberal premier whose policies led to this self-inflicted wound.

Then there’s the impact on the land. The more than 8,000 wind turbines Ontario had built each required an average of 3 acres of space. Many are near bird habitats, causing locals to label them “bird blenders”. Wind power’s numerous other environmental shortcomings have lately been coming to light. The massive turbine blades only last so long and, it turns out, cannot be recycled. They will need to be placed in landfills. The foundations required to keep the windmills standing in the face of nature’s forces consume enormous volumes of concrete. The generators inside the pods use rare-earth metals mined in part by African child labour. And in another ironic twist, China, the world’s largest emitter of greenhouse gases, produces most of the wind turbines that Western countries are spending billions on in pursuit of their save-the-world-through-green-power fantasy.

Not so benign: Solar panels are “off” more than “on” while ruining valuable landscapes.

Even all this is only part of the story. Because – surprise – the wind blows irregularly, because solar panels are useless during Ontario’s long dark winter nights, and because there is no way to efficiently store electricity, several new natural gas-fired power plants were needed to back up those unreliable wind and solar facilities. The inefficient deployment of capital and the need to pay those providers for standing by pushed Ontario’s power prices even higher. The only winners from this made-in-Ontario fiasco were the so-called “green-preneurs” who became very wealthy from those locked-in power contracts.

Our eco-friendly future? Mass graves for wind blades. (Source: Benjamin Rasmussen / Getty Images)

The moral of this sad story is that the Trudeau Liberals’ plans to replace fossil fuels with wind and solar are technically impossible and economically disastrous. Moreover, phasing out the oilsands would simply hand even more of the global crude oil market to such sterling global citizens as Russia and Iran, while throwing more than 1 million Canadians out of work and destroying the country’s largest source of wealth generation and export revenues. All at a time when that wealth generation is needed more than ever.

Trying to solve any problem with a solution that defies the laws of physics is bound to fail. What can Canada actually do to help reduce global emissions and help the economy? That will be the subject of my next column.

Gwyn Morgan is the retired founding CEO of EnCana Corp., formerly Canada’s largest producer of natural gas.

Love C2C Journal? Here's how you can help us grow.

More for you

The (Un)Remarkable Common Sense Revolution of Mike Harris

To his fans, former Ontario premier Mike Harris is a conservative icon, a leader who cut taxes, reduced government spending, made sensible education and welfare reforms and put Canada’s biggest province back on the road to prosperity. To his enemies he was a ruthless ideologue whose “Common Sense Revolution” ignored the weak and punished the poor. A new book of essays by seasoned political campaigners and prominent policy experts re-examines this polarizing figure and finds both strengths and weaknesses. Harris’ success on the big issues of the day, finds reviewer Sam Routley, shows that when it comes to actually governing a democracy, what matters most is a clear-headed willingness to just get things done.

State of Fear: How Obsessive Demands for Police Checks are Destroying the Volunteer Sector

Everyone wants to protect children. Everyone also appreciates the benefits of a robust and engaged volunteer sector. We should be able to have both at the same time. Yet many long-time volunteers are quitting and potential new entrants are skipping the experience altogether. With safety precautions overwhelming the volunteer sector, it is becoming increasingly difficult to give away one’s own labour. Using his personal experience as a guide, Peter Shawn Taylor takes a close look at the charitable sector’s current mania for police checks and other safety measures, the costs they impose on volunteers and whether they’re actually protecting our kids from sexual predators.

Hush Money: The Untold Dangers and Delusions of Central Bank Digital Currency

Most of us might think that, what with credit cards, e-transfers and online banking, money has pretty much already gone digital. But the Bank of Canada is busily working on a much bigger transformation. Canada is one of more than 100 countries worldwide that are studying, developing or even implementing central bank digital currency (CBDC). CBDC is marketed as a convenient replacement for cash once it disappears from use, as a way to provide access to financial services for the “underbanked,” and as a bulwark against volatile cryptocurrency. Gleb Lisikh untangles this little-known phenomenon and finds that, contrary to its billing, CBDC is both unnecessary and dangerous.

More from this author

Masters, Residents and 26-Hour Shifts: We Must Solve Canada’s Shortage of Family Doctors

Among the most painful aspects of Canada’s worsening health care crisis is the sheer lack of doctors, especially general practitioners or family physicians. One reason for this is the education system’s scant production of medical school graduates. Defects in Canada’s method of medical residency – professional apprenticeship – add further obstacles to the flow of new doctors. Drawing upon research into the numbers and nature of the medical education system plus personal experience, Gwyn Morgan lays bare the challenges faced by young residents and offers practical solutions that could help Canada produce more family doctors.

Ottawa’s Slavish Submission to Beijing’s Emissions Charade

In its fanatical drive for “net zero,” the Justin Trudeau government is eviscerating Canada’s manufacturing sector and imposing massive costs on Canadians, while dancing along to China’s charade that it intends to reduce its own greenhouse gas emissions, even as the Communist regime oversees record construction of new carbon-spewing, coal-fired power plants. The economic wellbeing of Canadians is, in other words, being progressively destroyed – and for nothing. It is time to wake up from this absurdist slumber, writes Gwyn Morgan, and also offers a formula for Canada to assign the costs of carbon emissions where they actually belong, rescue the nation’s manufacturing sector before it’s too late, lift the carbon tax burden from Canadians and, perhaps, even help the global environment.

Hara-Kiri Trudeau Style

When does a once-lofty ideal that some time ago degenerated into blind dogma collapse further into suicide cult? Right about now, when it comes to “save the planet” by forcing Canada to “net zero.” Gwyn Morgan charts the Trudeau government’s further ratcheting up of taxes and regulatory burdens on Canada’s hard-pressed consumers, businesses and the energy sector, all in the name of fighting climate change to which Canada’s contribution is barely a rounding error – while the big emitters like China get a free pass from the Trudeau government itself.

Share This Story


Subscribe to the C2C Weekly
It's Free!

* indicates required
By providing your email you consent to receive news and updates from C2C Journal. You may unsubscribe at any time.