Carbon Politics

Ottawa’s Slavish Submission to Beijing’s Emissions Charade

Gwyn Morgan
September 23, 2023
In its fanatical drive for “net zero,” the Justin Trudeau government is eviscerating Canada’s manufacturing sector and imposing massive costs on Canadians, while dancing along to China’s charade that it intends to reduce its own greenhouse gas emissions, even as the Communist regime oversees record construction of new carbon-spewing, coal-fired power plants. The economic wellbeing of Canadians is, in other words, being progressively destroyed – and for nothing. It is time to wake up from this absurdist slumber, writes Gwyn Morgan, and also offers a formula for Canada to assign the costs of carbon emissions where they actually belong, rescue the nation’s manufacturing sector before it’s too late, lift the carbon tax burden from Canadians and, perhaps, even help the global environment.
Carbon Politics

Ottawa’s Slavish Submission to Beijing’s Emissions Charade

Gwyn Morgan
September 23, 2023
In its fanatical drive for “net zero,” the Justin Trudeau government is eviscerating Canada’s manufacturing sector and imposing massive costs on Canadians, while dancing along to China’s charade that it intends to reduce its own greenhouse gas emissions, even as the Communist regime oversees record construction of new carbon-spewing, coal-fired power plants. The economic wellbeing of Canadians is, in other words, being progressively destroyed – and for nothing. It is time to wake up from this absurdist slumber, writes Gwyn Morgan, and also offers a formula for Canada to assign the costs of carbon emissions where they actually belong, rescue the nation’s manufacturing sector before it’s too late, lift the carbon tax burden from Canadians and, perhaps, even help the global environment.
Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter

My previous article, focussing on the destructive impact of the increasing motor-fuel carbon taxes that are a key feature of the Justin Trudeau government’s climate change policies, included the following comment: “The Parliamentary Budget Officer has concluded that these rising motor fuel taxes are ‘broadly regressive,’ meaning that the economic impact will fall disproportionately on lower-income people already struggling to pay the rising cost of groceries and other necessities…And the cost of all their necessities will, in turn, be driven even higher by carbon taxes levied on the fuels used in their production and delivery. How ironic that a self-described ‘progressive’ Liberal government kept in power by the deeply socialist NDP – both of which are allegedly dedicated to protecting the poor – is fighting a war on carbon emissions on the backs of those who can least afford it.”

Necessary sacrifice? Following Canada’s devastating wildfire season, the Trudeau government’s carbon emission reduction policy may seem like the lesser of two evils in addressing the global climate “emergency.” Yet even if Canada reached “net zero,” there would be no notable impact on the world’s total emissions. On top, the Lower East Adams Lake wildfire burning in Scotch Creek, B.C., August 2023. (Sources: (photo) The Canadian Press/Darryl Dyck; (image) RBC)

After a devastating wildfire season, which many politicians and much of the mainstream news media attributed to climate change, it’s understandable that many Canadians may be wondering if paying those rising carbon taxes – scheduled to hit $95 per tonne of carbon dioxide emissions the year after next – may be a sacrifice we must make to fight the purported climate “emergency.” But would those carbon taxes make any difference whatsoever? My article pointed out that calculations using data from the government’s own Greenhouse Gas Emissions website show that, if all gasoline and diesel-powered vehicles in Canada were taken off the road for a full year, the total emissions avoided would offset China’s emissions for just 56 hours.

And that brings me to the focus of this article. China’s annual CO2 emissions have skyrocketed from 3.6 billion tonnes in 2000 to an estimated 11.5 billion tonnes in 2021, according to Statista. The country is now responsible for more CO2 emissions than the United States, India, Indonesia, Russia, Brazil, Japan and the 27-country European Union – combined. And China’s emissions continue to grow unchecked even as those of many other countries are relatively flat or even declining. The U.S., often portrayed as the world’s worst polluter, greatly reduced its overall emissions in the 2010-2020 period and currently emits less than half as much COas China. (Canada’s emissions, on a global scale, represent barely more than a rounding error.)

China has long promised to reduce emissions from coal-fired electricity generating stations, but it’s clear those promises are just a charade. Last year, China’s government granted construction permits for the equivalent of two large new coal-burning power plants – every week. That was some 106,000 megawatts of new capacity approved over the course of the year, four times as much as the year before. It also represents more than 10 times the capacity of all the coal-fired plants that Alberta has taken out of service over the past decade. China now has six times more coal plants under construction than the rest of the world combined. Moreover, while China touts the ostensible environmental benefits as the world’s dominant manufacturer of wind turbine blades and solar panels, the use of coal-power to manufacture them offsets much of the eventual environmental benefit.

Mere charade: Despite China’s many promises to reduce emissions from its coal-fired plants, the Communist regime is obviously not planning to deliver. In the last year alone, China approved construction permits equivalent to building two new coal-burning power plants per week. (Sources: (graph) CREA; (photo) AP Photo/Sam McNeil, File)

China’s charades haven’t deterred federal Minister of Environment and Climate Change Steven Guilbeault from accepting appointment as the Executive Vice-Chair of the so-called China Council for International Cooperation on Environment and Development (CCICED). Nor have they prevented the Liberal government from sending taxpayers’ money to help fund it. But the CCICED isn’t really an international environmental cooperation entity. It’s run entirely by Beijing – meaning it is yet another front for the Communist Party of China and its many nefarious activities around the world, including interfering in Canada’s elections and operating secret police stations in our country.

This “council” is clearly aimed at simply perpetuating the myth of Chinese environmental responsibility. But Guilbeault, a man whose environmental fanaticism is exceeded only by his naïveté, journeyed to a recent CCICED meeting in Beijing, fantasizing publicly that he could actually get China to agree to “a global renewable energy target.” As the saying goes, not bloody likely. The Chinese state-controlled media (i.e., propaganda organs) immediately slapped down the upstart Quebecker.

What are the odds: Steven Guilbeault (top), federal Minister of Environment and Climate Change and newly appointed Executive Vice-Chair of the Council for International Cooperation on Environment and Development (CCICED) – controlled by China’s Communist regime – expressed hopes of persuading China to agree to “a global renewable energy target.” (Sources of photos: (top) UN Biodiversity/Flickr, licensed under CC BY 2.0; (bottom) WBCSD)

Data from the World Bank show that China’s greenhouse gas emissions per unit of GDP – what is known as “emissions intensity” – are two-and-a-half times as high as in North America. Moreover, since zero-emissions hydropower provides nearly 60 percent of Canada’s electricity and much of the rest is supplied by low-emission natural gas, Canadian manufactured goods are vastly less emissions-intensive than most goods imported from China. This means that one of the best things Canada could do to help reduce global COemissions would be to replace Chinese imports with goods manufactured at home. National borders are, after all, irrelevant to atmospheric gases, so it shouldn’t matter where emissions are cut. The other would be to greatly accelerate construction of liquefied natural gas (LNG) export facilities so that other countries could replace dirtier electricity production with clean-burning Canadian natural gas, but that is the subject of another article.

Instead, the Trudeau government is burdening our manufacturers with progressively higher carbon taxes that affect costs all along their supply chains. Canadian manufacturers are already struggling to survive. A report last year from the Canadian Manufacturers and Exporters (CME) underlines the challenges facing Canadian manufacturers, even before the staggering costs of the government’s “net zero” policy. “To achieve net zero,” the report stated, “CME estimates that Canadian manufacturers will need to invest $6 billion per year in emissions technology alone…while still trying to invest in capital programs.”

But that investment capital is increasingly scarce: between 2015 and 2019, Canada attracted less than $22 billion of the $1.77 trillion invested annually in manufacturing. Global investors, banks and manufacturers just don’t regard Canada as a good place in which to commit capital and establish new facilities any longer – unless those facilities happen to be prodigiously subsidized, as shown by the recent tens of billions of taxpayers’ dollars promised to Stellantis and VW for electric vehicle battery manufacturing plants in Ontario.

Meanwhile, Canadian imports of Chinese manufactured goods reached a record $100 billion in 2022. So why is the Trudeau government eviscerating Canadian manufacturing and burdening all Canadian businesses and individuals with debilitating carbon taxes while we import ever-increasing amounts of carbon-intensive Chinese goods? The answer to that question may elude Trudeau’s carbon tax-fixated government.

Steep hill to climb: To achieve “net zero,” Canadian manufacturers will need to invest $6 billion per year in new emissions-reduction technology. Capital investment for all purposes combined has been averaging only slightly more than $20 billion per year. (Sources: (photo) ArcelorMittal Dofasco, retrieved from Steel Times International; (graph) retrieved from Canada’s Net Zero Industrial Strategy by Canadian Manufacturers and Exporters, June 2022)

But the solution is obvious: take the carbon taxes off the shoulders of Canadians and transfer them to carbon-spewing Chinese imports. The mechanism would be to categorize the different types of imports by carbon intensity and set the tax rate accordingly. This may seem like a complex process, but it’s vastly simpler than the mish-mash of regulations facing Canadian businesses under the job-killing Trudeau/Guilbeault carbon tax. China’s emissions charade has gone on far too long. It’s time to lift the carbon tax burden from the shoulders of Canadians and place it where it might actually help the planet.

Gwyn Morgan is a retired business leader who was a director of five global corporations.

Source of main image: Shutterstock.

Love C2C Journal? Here's how you can help us grow.

More for you

They Would Call Me a “Denier” – Let Me Explain what I Believe about Residential Schools in Canada

In our largely “post-truth” society, the validity of a given statement is increasingly assessed based on who is making it. There are even those who believe that only some should be allowed to say certain things – while others should be scorned or even imprisoned for uttering the same words. This increasingly describes the discursive landscape concerning Canada’s Indian Residential Schools and whether Indigenous children disappeared from and/or were murdered there. Drawing on his lived experience as a onetime residential school employee, on his long academic record and, not least, on his personal courage in the face of those who wish to criminalize “denialism”, Rodney Clifton presents a humbly argued plea for Canadians to judge their country’s residential school record according to the truth – the actual, factual truth.

One Job We Can’t Let AI Replace: Philosopher. Rethinking the Ethics of Artificial Intelligence

We stand on the precipice of a new technological age. Artificial intelligence promises (or threatens) to upend every aspect of modern life – from employment to entertainment, manufacturing to warfare – as well as the very relationship between humanity and the machinery it creates. Given AI’s potentially cataclysmic consequences, D.C.C. Randell argues it is imperative that we set not merely regulatory and technical boundaries around its development, but ethical ones as well. Combining the warnings of current AI experts with the wisdom of philosophers and moralists from past ages, Randell explains the dangers posed by allowing the AI revolution to continue unfettered and proposes steps to bring it in line.

Arresting Developments: The Persecution of David Menzies and the Fight for Media Freedom in Canada

The sight of a journalist getting roughed up and hustled off by police as he tries to ask a question of a public figure in a public place is one you might expect to witness in a banana republic or present-day Russia. But it has happened four times in Canada just this year to veteran journalist David Menzies of Rebel News. Menzies is an old-fashioned street journalist – right down to his trademark fedora – asking straight questions and digging for the truth no matter the consequences. In this instalment of C2C’s Courageous Canadians series, Associate Editor Brock Eldon sits down with Menzies to talk about his run-ins with the law, his determination to publish without fear or favour, and the state of Canadian journalism.

More from this author

The Pawns Push Back against the Trudeau Government’s Electric Vehicle Diktats

Perhaps there is a certain twisted logic to the woke left’s attempt to convince schoolchildren that math is racist and that 2 plus 2 might well equal 5. For this may be the only way to get the “math” surrounding the Justin Trudeau government’s push to force Canadians into buying only electric vehicles as of 2035 to work in any way at all. Gwyn Morgan reviews the actual math of key elements of the EV transition scheme – the electric power needs, the subsidized purchases, the tax credits, the vast number of required charging stations, the maintenance of roads – and finds both the costs and the implementation obstacles to be a mixture of steep, dubious and prohibitive. So much so, Morgan concludes, as to cast the entire EV transition in doubt.

A Wealth-Creating Way of Reducing Global CO2 Emissions

It is Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s contention there’s no “business case” for exporting Canada’s abundant, inexpensively produced natural gas as LNG. But Canadians might do well to politely decline management consulting advice from a former substitute drama teacher who was born into wealth and has never had to meet a payroll, balance a budget or make a sale. Bluntly stated, someone who has shown no evidence of being able to run the proverbial lemonade stand. And one whose real agenda, the evidence shows, is to strangle the nation’s most productive and wealth-generating industry. With the first LNG ship finally expected to dock at Kitimat, B.C. over the next year and load Canada’s first-ever LNG export cargo, Gwyn Morgan lays out the business and environmental cases for ramping up our LNG exports – and having them count towards Canada’s greenhouse gas reduction targets.

The Worrisome Wave of Politicized Prosecutions

Shaping criminal charges, bail decisions or prison sentences around an accused person’s political or religious beliefs is utterly odious – a hallmark of tinpot tyrannies and totalitarian hellholes. Such practices have no place in any constitutional nation, let alone a mature democracy that presents itself as a model to the world. But that is increasingly the situation in Canada, writes Gwyn Morgan. Comparing the treatment of protesters accused of minor infractions to those of incorrigible criminals who maim and kill, Morgan finds a yawning mismatch that suggests political motivations are increasingly a factor in today’s criminal justice system.

Share This Story

Donate

Subscribe to the C2C Weekly
It's Free!

* indicates required
Interests
By providing your email you consent to receive news and updates from C2C Journal. You may unsubscribe at any time.