Anti-Semitism

Quick Read

What if October 7 Had Happened Not in Israel but in Canada?

Gwyn Morgan
October 10, 2025
It is probably beyond the imagination of most Canadians that they would ever face the kind of evil atrocity Israelis suffered on October 7, 2023. Or that we would find ourselves living next door to savage terrorists bent on our annihilation. But as Gwyn Morgan points out, it is critical to understand that reality as Israel’s struggle for existence carries on. The history of Israel is nothing short of miraculous. As Morgan personally observed on a tour of the world’s only Jewish state, Israelis have with determination and heart built a free, tolerant, prosperous and technologically-advanced democracy while surrounded by enemies. In the face of ruthless attacks by Hamas and the craven behaviour of supposed friends and allies who now lean in favour of the terrorists, Israel has reminded the rest of the world what real courage is.
Anti-Semitism

Quick Read

What if October 7 Had Happened Not in Israel but in Canada?

Gwyn Morgan
October 10, 2025
It is probably beyond the imagination of most Canadians that they would ever face the kind of evil atrocity Israelis suffered on October 7, 2023. Or that we would find ourselves living next door to savage terrorists bent on our annihilation. But as Gwyn Morgan points out, it is critical to understand that reality as Israel’s struggle for existence carries on. The history of Israel is nothing short of miraculous. As Morgan personally observed on a tour of the world’s only Jewish state, Israelis have with determination and heart built a free, tolerant, prosperous and technologically-advanced democracy while surrounded by enemies. In the face of ruthless attacks by Hamas and the craven behaviour of supposed friends and allies who now lean in favour of the terrorists, Israel has reminded the rest of the world what real courage is.
Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter

European Jews had faced anti-Semitism-fuelled persecution for centuries before Adolf Hitler’s plan to exterminate every Jew saw more than 6 million lose their lives in the most horribly unimaginable ways. What isn’t as well-known, especially among today’s younger generations, is that anti-Semitism was common in Europe well before the Holocaust. So it is little wonder that once the Second World War ended, many surviving Jews recoiled at the thought of returning to the European countries of which they had been loyal and proud citizens. Instead, it was only logical – as well as satisfying a deep, eternal longing in the Jewish heart – to move to the region where the Israeli people had originated 24 centuries ago and where many still lived.

Since 1917, the British had administered what had latterly been named Palestine. There had long been an active movement – Zionism – that sought to repatriate Jews to their ancient homeland and, it was hoped, form an independent Jewish state for the first time in nearly 2,000 years. In late 1947, the newly created United Nations resolved that the British Mandate territory was to be split into a zone for Arabs called Palestine and a zone for Jews called Israel. On May 14, 1948, Israel declared its independence and the British Army departed.

Born in war: In 1948, the British Mandate territory was split into a zone for Arabs called Palestine and a zone for Jews called Israel; the new state of Israel came under immediate attack by the armies of Egypt, Jordan, Syria, Lebanon and Iraq as well as local Arab militias. Shown: (left) A 1947 UN map of the proposed partition; (right) units of the nascent Israel Defense Forces (right) during Operation Horev in 1948. Zionism_October 7_history of Israel_iron dome_1
xBorn in war: In 1948, the British Mandate territory was split into a zone for Arabs called Palestine and a zone for Jews called Israel; the new state of Israel came under immediate attack by the armies of Egypt, Jordan, Syria, Lebanon and Iraq as well as local Arab militias. Shown at left, a 1947 UN map of the proposed partition; at right, units of the nascent Israel Defense Forces during Operation Horev in 1948.

The very next day, the infant state of Israel came under attack by the armies of Egypt, Jordan, Syria, Lebanon and Iraq as well as local Arab militias. The Israelis were given zero chance of winning. A tiny country of 800,000 people with only untested militias and a motley collection of hand-me-down weaponry going up against well-equipped, formally trained armies made victory inconceivable. Miraculously, not only did Israel win, it captured large additional territories geographically vital to the country’s future defence. (For those interested in that improbable outcome but not inclined to plough through history books, I can recommend the movies Exodus with Paul Newman and Eva Marie Saint, and Cast a Giant Shadow with Kirk Douglas and Senta Berger.)

How could this be possible? I got an answer to that question one evening in Tel Aviv. I was privileged to be part of a private tour of Israel hosted by the government with security provided by the Israel Defense Forces. We met with a remarkable 35-year-old female unit commander tasked with protecting the Lebanon-facing Golan Heights border area from attacks by Hezbollah terrorists. Her answer to my question was both brief and profound: Heart. Half an hour later, her pager buzzed. Hezbollah was attacking the Golan Heights just above our meeting place. She ran to her waiting helicopter.

The Second World War’s aftermath became a pivotal phase in the history of Israel, as it enabled the country’s founding. European Jews had faced centuries of anti-Semitism, which culminated in the Holocaust and the murder of more than 6 million people. After the war ended, many surviving Jews recoiled at the thought of returning to the European countries of which they had been citizens. Instead, it was a logical step for them to move to their ancestral homeland, a goal that fulfilled the aspirations of Zionism, a long-active movement that sought to form an independent Jewish state. This movement culminated on May 14, 1948, when Israel, in keeping with a United Nations resolution the previous year, declared its independence as a Jewish state.

That Israeli army commander’s single word put so much in perspective. The Oxford English Dictionary defines courage as bravery or strength in the face of pain or grief. The Latin root word for courage is “heart”. The postwar Jews who streamed to their ancestral homeland in decrepit steamships knew that Israel was their last chance. There was nowhere else to go. The enemy soldiers’ massive advantage in numbers and weaponry made them confident the conflict would be over in hours. They never expected to face adversaries fully prepared to die. Terrified by that fearless ferocity, as the 14-month War of Independence went on, more and more they turned and ran.

Since that incredible victory in 1949, driven by constant threats from surrounding Islamist enemies, Israel went on to build one of the world’s most technologically advanced, tactically innovative and well-trained defence forces. Here is a very quick look at the two other make-or-break confrontations Israel faced. First came the so-called Six-Day War of 1967. When Israel’s famed Mossad intelligence agency learned of an imminent attack by Egypt, Jordan and Syria, Israel attacked pre-emptively, all-but wiping out Egypt’s much superior air force while its fighter jets were still parked on the ground, then launching a lightning ground campaign that seized the Sinai Peninsula, West Bank of the Jordan River and Golan Heights.

A test of courage and heart: In 1973, Egypt and Syria launched a surprise attack on the Jewish holy day of Yom Kippur; Israeli forces regrouped and mounted a fierce counterattack – a turning point that showcased the country’s capability and resolve. Shown, IDF tanks and an armoured vehicle during the Yom Kippur War. Zionism_October 7_history of Israel_iron dome_2
xA test of courage and heart: In 1973, Egypt and Syria launched a surprise attack on the Jewish holy day of Yom Kippur; Israeli forces regrouped and mounted a fierce counterattack – a turning point that showcased the country’s capability and resolve. Shown, IDF tanks and an armoured vehicle during the Yom Kippur War. (Source of bottom photo: Israel Press and Photo Agency/Dan Hadani collection, National Library of Israel, licensed under CC BY 4.0)

Six years later, on the holy day of Yom Kippur – October 6 – Egypt and Syria launched a massive surprise attack that caught Israel completely off-guard. Egypt envisioned quickly recapturing the Sinai while Syria drove across the Golan Heights; Israel’s annihilation was intended to follow. After some very tense days and fearsome losses of soldiers and aircraft, Israel turned the tables, recaptured the lost ground and very likely could have driven all the way to Damascus and Cairo.

Amidst these and other tumultuous events, the history of Israel has included building one of the world’s most tolerant and technically advanced democracies. Our tour group noted no discrimination against minority groups. The country’s currently 2 million Sunni Muslim citizens are considered equals to its nearly 8 million Jews. An Israeli Arab, Khaled Kabub, is a Justice on Israel’s Supreme Court.

Israel is also home to a small population of Druze, an Abrahamic faith descended but now very different from Shia Islam. Arrangements had been made for us to have lunch at the home of a Druze family. It was a memorable experience. The eldest of the three children helped her mom prepare the meal, while her brother prepared the table. And the bubbly little girl entertained us. While the Druze largely inhabit their own enclave, they are otherwise integrated into Israeli society, fiercely loyal to the State of Isarel, and serve proudly in the military. The Israelis considers the Druze brethren, protecting them from persecution throughout the Middle East, including in Lebanon and Syria. The IDF’s recent airstrikes in western Syria near the Golan Heights were partly aimed at protecting Syria’s Druze population when it came under attack from Sunni Muslim extremists linked to Syria’s new regime.

Israel has one of the world’s most well-trained and technologically-advanced militaries, including its Iron Dome air defence system that intercepts incoming missiles launched by hostile states or terrorist forces. Zionism_October 7_history of Israel_iron dome_3
xIsrael has one of the world’s most well-trained and technologically-advanced militaries, including its Iron Dome air defence system that intercepts incoming missiles launched by hostile states or terrorist forces. (Source of photo: Shutterstock)

During our 2019 visit, our group was also taken to an amazing technology centre and toured a factory producing advanced products for sectors from aerospace to defence. Having been a professional engineer throughout my career, I found this fascinating. Much of our digital world runs on Israeli technology. NVIDIA, Apple and Intel’s chips are designed in Israel’s development centres. Michael Kagan, Global Chief Technology Officer of NVIDIA, the world’s top computer-chip design firm by market capitalization, lives in Tel Aviv, the country’s commercial capital. Israel’s extraordinary Iron Dome and Arrow air-defence systems that shoot down terrorist missiles fired by Hezbollah in Lebanon, Houthis in Yemen, Hamas in Gaza and Iran’s mullahs have been crucial to saving the country from devastation.

But now the long-suffering Israelis have been attacked by people whose tactics can’t be stopped by technology like Iron Dome and whose driving objective, as was Hitler’s, is to wipe them off the face of the Earth. Hamas, an acronym for “Islamic Resistance Movement”, is committed to “armed resistance to Israel and creation of a Palestinian State.” Israel’s invasion of Gaza in late 2023 in response to the October 7 incursion by the vicious Hamas throat-slitters and kidnappers has engendered intense criticism and worsened longstanding anti-Semitism. It may be hard for many to watch the death and destruction occurring in Gaza without experiencing those emotions. But we need to put ourselves in the Israelis’ shoes, and we need to ask ourselves an important question. What would we do?

A good portion of the world runs on Israeli technology, including cutting-edge chips designed for the likes of NVIDIA, Apple and Intel. Shown at left, the headquarters of AI powerhouse NVIDIA Israel in Tel Aviv; at right, Michael Kagan, NVIDIA Chief Technology Officer). Zionism_October 7_history of Israel_iron dome_4
xA good portion of the world runs on Israeli technology, including cutting-edge chips designed for the likes of NVIDIA, Apple and Intel. Shown at left, the headquarters of AI powerhouse NVIDIA Israel in Tel Aviv; at right, Michael Kagan, NVIDIA Chief Technology Officer. (Sources of photos: (left) Igal Vaisman/Shuttestock; (right) YouTube/NetEvents International)

Imagine we Canadians are living on the other side of a security fence from a territory populated by Islamic terrorists whose sole avowed objective is to annihilate every one of us. Imagine also that they continually fire lethal rockets into civilian areas, necessitating every home to have a bomb-proof “safe space”. Then one night, as a large group of happy young people dance to music at a festival, the terrorists burst through the security fence using construction equipment while hundreds of others swoop in from above on powered paragliders.

They fall upon that group of happy young Canadians, who are then viciously tortured and raped, followed by genital mutilation and murder, all proudly recorded on GoPro cameras or smartphones. One of the terrorists even uses a murdered young woman’s phone to call his family. “Hi Dad, open my WhatsApp and see how many I killed with my own hands. I killed ten! Put mom on…Mom, your son is a hero, Kill Kill Kill!” “Oh my son, God bless you,” the ecstatic mother replies. (Note: These quotes are not made up but are from a transcript of phone recordings recovered by Israeli authorities.)

The day after its declaration of independence on May 14, 1948, Israel was attacked by the armies of Egypt, Jordan, Syria, Lebanon and Iraq. Despite having only untested militias against well-equipped armies, 14 months later the Israelis triumphed in what became known as the War of Independence. Some attribute this victory against seemingly impossible odds to the “heart” and fearless ferocity of the infant state’s citizens, who were fighting for their last chance at a homeland and were fully prepared to die. Since that time, Israel has built one of the world’s most technologically advanced defence forces. In the Six-Day War of 1967, it launched a successful pre-emptive attack, and in 1973, it recovered from a surprise attack starting the Yom Kippur War to drive back invading forces. Israel’s current defences include advanced domestically-developed systems like the Iron Dome and Arrow, which protect it from missile attacks.

Then, those still living are loaded onto trucks heading back to the perpetrators’ territory, there to be held as hostages in a huge multi-million-dollar underground tunnel network funded in part, ironically, by donations from UNRWA, the United Nations Relief and Works Agency. UNRWA employees are later found to have not only supported but directly participated in the terrorist acts.

In response to this unspeakable atrocity, democratic and peace-seeking Canada retaliates strongly, sending tens of thousands of soldiers to recover the kidnapped hostages – many of whom have been repeatedly raped, tortured, starved or forced to perform humiliating labour for the terrorists and their families – while attempting to minimize casualties among the enemy’s civilian population. But, knowing that ongoing civilian deaths will trigger international condemnation – the more, the greater – the terrorists use their own population as human shields, forcing them to live in the above-ground battle zone while they themselves hunker down in reinforced tunnels. (In the Second World War, by contrast, not only the British but even the Nazi Germans put their civilians in shelters while remaining above ground to fight.)

What if this had happened in Canada? The massacre of October 7, 2023 saw Hamas terrorists kill 1,405 people, including more than 370 at the Nova music festival in the Negev desert; hundreds more were taken hostage, raped and tortured. Shown at top, Hamas fighters taking captured Israeli civilian into the Gaza Strip; at bottom, a commemorative site in memory of the massacre, Kibbutz Reim. Zionism_October 7_history of Israel_iron dome_5
xWhat if this had happened in Canada? The massacre of October 7, 2023 saw Hamas terrorists kill 1,405 people, including more than 370 at the Nova music festival in the Negev desert; hundreds more were taken hostage, raped and tortured. Shown at top, Hamas fighters taking captured Israeli civilian into the Gaza Strip; at bottom, a commemorative site in memory of the massacre, Kibbutz Reim. (Sources of photos: (top two) AP; (bottom) זאב שטיין, licensed under CC BY 2.5)

But rather than recognizing that our country’s survival left us with no other choice, a huge upwelling of support for the terrorists sweeps through countries and infects governments that we thought were our friends, allies and supporters. Virtually limitless Muslim immigration to those countries has resulted in a hugely belligerent and electorally significant population segment. Our own prime minister then admits that our country has become more economically and politically isolated – but, rather than caving to international pressure, will have to become more self-reliant. Shifting back to the current literal reality of Israel, the good news is that no other country in the world is more able to do just that. And so two years after the October 7, 2023 atrocity, Israel’s fight for a just result – victory over Hamas, recovery of all hostages and official recognition by every Arab state of Israel’s right to live in peace as a Jewish state – goes on.

Gwyn Morgan is a retired business leader who was a director of five global corporations.

Source of main image: Omri Eliyahu/Shutterstock.

Love C2C Journal? Here's how you can help us grow.

More for you

Cash Constrained: Bill C-2 and Ottawa’s Plan to End Paper Money

“Cash is king, credit is a slave,” George N. McLean wrote in his classic 1890 book How to do Business. More than a century later, it’s still good advice – one that active pro-cash movements in many other countries are recognizing. So why does Ottawa seem determined to put its own banknotes out of commission? In the name of fighting international money-launderers, the Mark Carney government is proposing to outlaw all larger cash transactions and interfere with other key aspects of Canada’s cash economy. Through interviews with experts in business, social policy and politics, Peter Shawn Taylor examines the varied benefits cash provides and asks who stands to gain from a truly cashless society.

Holy Horror: The Campaign to Kill Off Canada’s Religious Charities

The modern welfare state owes much of its origins to religion. Blessed with ample resources and driven by a moral duty to improve the lives of those in their care, churches and religious orders in the Middle Ages created the first universities, hospitals, homeless shelters and food banks. More recently, however, the pendulum of power has swung mightily in favour of secular government. And now, with church attendance on the wane, those secular forces seem determined to destroy their spiritual competition once and for all. Examining a potentially devastating federal proposal to strip religious organizations of their charitable status, Anna Farrow considers the impact churches play in today’s civil society – and wonders how Canada’s less fortunate would fare in a world bereft of faith.

A writer's return reveals a nation in rot, challenging the Canadian identity and exploring the disillusionment that makes one consider leaving Canada.

Drift or North: A Return from Exile and the Idea of the North

After more than a decade living in the crush and chaos of Southeast Asia, writer Brock Eldon came back to Canada to root his young family in a place of promise and possibility. He found instead a country in an advanced state of administrative rot and a people who have abandoned ambition for shallow self-righteousness. In this provocative literary essay, Eldon explores the North he long imagined and discovers that returning is not the same as belonging.

More from this author

Dead Wait: Canada’s Fatal Obsession with Public Health Care

Canada spends more on health care than just about any other country in the world, and with abysmal results. Yet when it comes to fixing the problem, most politicians and policy-makers are immune to common sense. As business leader Gwyn Morgan writes, allowing private options alongside government-funded health care has been proven to help patients in both systems – around the world and here in Canada, too. Yet the courts continued to uphold restrictions on private care while the Mark Carney government simply promises to throw still more money at the problem – showing itself to be as deluded and dogmatic as those who went before.

“Owe Canada”: Our Nation’s Looming Fiscal Abyss

For anyone who still bought into Mark Carney’s self-declared image as the great global banker who would responsibly manage Canada’s finances, his recent promise to juice defence spending to 5 percent of GDP – $155 billion per year in today’s dollars – must surely be the final straw. The Liberal Prime Minister had already announced massive spending hikes and a huge deficit, with interest on the federal debt to hit $70 billion by 2029. All this will spell doom for a country already struggling with declining productivity, zero growth and a falling standard of living, concludes Gwyn Morgan. The veteran business leader charts Canada’s path to budgetary disaster and places the blame squarely where it belongs – on Canada’s profligate Prime Minister.

Restoring Canada Special Series
Part II: Carney’s Energy Policy and the Fragile Canadian Economy

“Meet the new boss/Same as the old boss,” The Who’s Pete Townshend wrote back in 1971. Words that today might well apply to Mark Carney. Canada’s new Liberal Prime Minister says he wants to make Canada a “conventional and clean energy superpower”, and suddenly seems to support new oil and natural gas pipelines. But Gwyn Morgan, who devoted years as a CEO to defending Canada’s oil and natural gas industry, doesn’t buy it. Carney, he notes, spent years abroad on an ever-more-strident net-zero quest, and recently said he’s keeping his predecessor’s oil and gas emissions cap in place. In this incisive critique, Morgan takes the measure of the new PM and finds that the prospects of restoring the Canadian economy have dimmed further.