Pandemic Fallout

The Greedy Ones: Comparing Public and Private Sector Compensation in Canada

Gwyn Morgan
September 10, 2022
Scientists may never trace the origin of our sudden contagion of shameless posing, credit-grabbing and self-pity – yet this strange syndrome proliferated throughout the pandemic. And it lingers still. The most recent outbreak can be found within the leadership of those who suffered the least during Covid-19 – unionized public sector workers. Now these unions are demanding extra compensation for… well, it’s not clear for what exactly. As the demands from this comfortable class grow, the gap between them and the rest of the economy becomes ever-wider. Gwyn Morgan lays out the facts and fundamental injustice of the expanding gulf in compensation between Canada’s public and private sectors – and the harm it is doing to societal cohesion.
Pandemic Fallout

The Greedy Ones: Comparing Public and Private Sector Compensation in Canada

Gwyn Morgan
September 10, 2022
Scientists may never trace the origin of our sudden contagion of shameless posing, credit-grabbing and self-pity – yet this strange syndrome proliferated throughout the pandemic. And it lingers still. The most recent outbreak can be found within the leadership of those who suffered the least during Covid-19 – unionized public sector workers. Now these unions are demanding extra compensation for… well, it’s not clear for what exactly. As the demands from this comfortable class grow, the gap between them and the rest of the economy becomes ever-wider. Gwyn Morgan lays out the facts and fundamental injustice of the expanding gulf in compensation between Canada’s public and private sectors – and the harm it is doing to societal cohesion.
Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter

Most Canadians seem to believe the pandemic’s impact is in the rear-view mirror. But this isn’t the case for a great many small businesses that were forced to shutter their premises due to “safety concerns” even as customers packed into Covid-19-spreading lines to enter “necessary” big box stores. Behind each of those small businesses are not only the employees but the people who’ve invested personal savings and long hours to follow their ambitions and achieve their dreams. The Canadian Federation of Independent Business (CFIB) reports that in the first quarter of this year – a time when the direct effect of Covid-19 was generally easing to that of a serious cold – insolvencies among small businesses were up by 34 percent year-over-year, the biggest increase in more than 30 years.

xBarely hanging on: Canadian Federation of Independent Business president Dan Kelly (bottom) reports insolvencies among small businesses in Canada are up 34 percent in the post-Covid-19 era. (Sources of photos: (top) Shutterstock; (bottom) BNN Bloomberg)

Many other small businesses are just barely hanging on. CFIB President Dan Kelly fears the wave of defaults will continue to rise as higher interest rates on debt taken on to survive the pandemic will become “the straw that breaks the camel’s back.” And that’s to say nothing of the impacts of inflation, which have raised nearly all types of business costs, often suddenly and significantly eroding, if not erasing, small-business profit margins.  

Meanwhile, public-sector workers kept their jobs, added two years’ credit to their gilded pension benefits and even received wage increases – often for doing little or no real work while spending months at home. Statistics Canada’s January 2022 Labour Force Survey found that all of the country’s 206,000 job losses that month were private-sector employees. Public-sector employment, however, was 305,000 higher than at the beginning of the pandemic.

Not only did most public-sector workers maintain job security throughout this time, they also enjoyed vastly better pension and other benefits. A Fraser Institute report published around the beginning of the pandemic found that federal, provincial, and local government workers’ average wages were 9.4 percent higher than for their private-sector counterparts. Moreover, 88 percent of government workers were covered by a pension plan compared to fewer than 23 percent of private-sector workers.

The Great Divide: According to a 2020 Fraser Institute study, federal, provincial, and local government workers are paid on average 9.4 percent more than their private-sector counterparts and retire 2.4 years earlier. (Source of image: Comparing Government and Private Sector Compensation in Canada, 2020 by Fraser Institute)

But now it seems even the enormous compensation and job security advantages enjoyed by public-sector employees aren’t enough. The 120,000-member Public Service Alliance of Canada (PSAC), largest of 17 federal unions, in May voted to reinstate its internal provision for strike votes, which had been suspended during Covid-19. PSAC is seeking a 13.5 percent increase over three years. (Canada’s border guards did briefly go on strike last summer, but were quickly mollified with higher pay.) PSAC president Chris Aylward stated that, “The government can’t expect workers who have been getting us through the pandemic to shoulder the costs of Canada’s recovery.”

Shoulder the costs of Canada’s recovery? One wonders how that sounds to all those much lower-paid private-sector workers, many of whom either lost their jobs during the pandemic or were forced to work part-time. It is difficult to imagine a more clueless or plainly inaccurate statement. The union members who’ve actually been “getting us through the pandemic” aren’t Aylward’s at all, but are the hospital, care home and public health workers represented either by provincial unions or the Canadian Union of Public Employees. And then there are all the municipal workers, first responders, and the uncounted private-sector workers who kept performing the unsung and often repetitive jobs that really keep civilization going. 

xWhose shoulders? Chris Aylward, (top) president of Public Service Alliance of Canada, claims his workers deserve a 13.5 percent wage increase over the next three years because his members can’t be expected to “shoulder the costs of Canada’s recovery.” (Source of photos: PSAC)

Here in my home province, the 85,000-member B.C. General Employees’ Union (BCGEU), largest in the province, went on strike in mid-August demanding a wage raise of 5 percent in each of the next three years, or inflation adjustments. Whichever is higher. The union had broken off talks after receiving what union president Stephanie Smith disparagingly described as an “insulting” offer.

One of the first job actions taken by the BCGEU was aimed at distribution centres for government-run liquor stores, forcing the province to impose rationing that severely limited supplies to restaurants and bars during the peak summer season. A spokesman for the B.C. Restaurant and Food Services Association stated that the restriction “could not have come at a worse time for our industry that hasn’t recovered from the impact of the pandemic.”

The union recently reached a tentative agreement with the provincial government that includes significant wage hikes with built-in inflation protection. In the second year of the deal, for example, BCGEU workers will receive an increase of between 5.5 percent and 6.75 percent, depending on the inflation rate. With the BCGEU’s gambit having been proven successful, it seems likely B.C. will experience yet more strikes; 400,000 of the province’s workers have contracts expiring this year. The consequences will inflict mortal damage upon many financially fragile small businesses, adding to the already record number of insolvencies.

And that’s just in B.C. Ontario government data shows that 3,197 union contracts expire between now and year-end, two-thirds of which cover provincial employees. Government union contracts are also expiring in the other eight provinces. Strike-driven contract settlements will further increase the already huge gap between public and private compensation.

Throughout all of this, private-sector workers and their families are left struggling to pay for the rapidly rising cost of food, shelter, energy and other expenses. The great injustice is that it’s those lower-paid private-sector workers who generate such a large part of the taxes that governments use to pay the much higher wages and gilded benefits of union members. This financial disparity is profoundly damaging to the fabric of our society. But there’s another toll that may prove even worse and permanent: the contemptuous union strike behaviour that rubs salt into the financial and emotional wounds being felt by other Canadians.

xThroughout the pandemic, it has been private-sector workers who have shouldered the greatest burdens; further widening the gap between public and private-sector workers is not only unjust, it threatens grave damage to our social fabric. (Source of bottom left photo: Shutterstock)

Disparities between public and private compensation and job security have long existed in Canada. But the vastly worse financial and emotional toll experienced by private-sector workers over the past two years, combined with the shameless greed and selfishness of public-sector unions and, it seems, much of their membership, has widened those disparities to dangerous, societally divisive levels.

Two classes of Canadians have been created: those who pay and those who take, those insulated against any fundamental concerns about job security or income, and those whose ability to support themselves and their families depends on their own ability to create value for the enterprises that employ them.

The worst is yet to come. Bargaining for thousands of expiring government union contracts will harm many more businesses, further burden current and future taxpayers, and widen the dangerous gap between these two classes of Canadians. This is a time when our country needs strong, decisive federal and provincial leaders who will stand up against union demands, including using legislative powers where needed. I can’t say I’m optimistic we will see that kind of leadership.

Gwyn Morgan is a retired business leader who has been a director of five global corporations.

Love C2C Journal? Here's how you can help us grow.

More for you

Ottawa is Playing a Game of Charter Chicken with the Provinces

The federal government has long objected to provinces using the Charter of Rights and Freedoms’ “notwithstanding” clause, arguing it lets them trample over the rights of Canadians. But that view, flawed as it is, is nothing compared to Ottawa’s latest gambit on this issue, writes Andrew Roman. Liberal Justice Minister Sean Fraser’s recent intervention in the case of Quebec’s Bill 21 asks the Supreme Court of Canada to declare limits on the use of the notwithstanding clause. This would amount to a backdoor amendment of the Constitution by the court, one that would give judges even more power and leave elected representatives even less scope to avoid or undo their harmful decisions. More than just an attack on provincial autonomy, writes Roman, it threatens to upset the balance at the heart of Canada’s federal democracy.

What if October 7 Had Happened Not in Israel but in Canada?

It is probably beyond the imagination of most Canadians that they would ever face the kind of evil atrocity Israelis suffered on October 7, 2023. Or that we would find ourselves living next door to savage terrorists bent on our annihilation. But as Gwyn Morgan points out, it is critical to understand that reality as Israel’s struggle for existence carries on. The history of Israel is nothing short of miraculous. As Morgan personally observed on a tour of the world’s only Jewish state, Israelis have with determination and heart built a free, tolerant, prosperous and technologically-advanced democracy while surrounded by enemies. In the face of ruthless attacks by Hamas and the craven behaviour of supposed friends and allies who now lean in favour of the terrorists, Israel has reminded the rest of the world what real courage is.

One Country, Two Markets: The Shaky Promise and Unfair Burden of “Decarbonized” Oil

“Decarbonized” oil is being touted as a way to bridge the policy chasm separating energy-rich Alberta and the climate-change-obsessed Mark Carney government. Take the carbon dioxide normally emitted during the production and processing of crude oil and store it underground, the thinking goes, and Canada can have it all: plentiful jobs, a thriving industry, burgeoning exports and falling greenhouse gas emissions. But is “decarbonized” oil really a potential panacea – or an oxymoron that makes no more sense than “dehydrated” water? In this original analysis, former National Energy Board member Ron Wallace evaluates whether a massive push for carbon capture and storage can transform Alberta into a “clean energy superpower” – or will merely saddle its industry and government with a technical boondoggle and unbearable costs while Eastern Canada’s refiners remain free to import dirty oil from abroad.

More from this author

What if October 7 Had Happened Not in Israel but in Canada?

It is probably beyond the imagination of most Canadians that they would ever face the kind of evil atrocity Israelis suffered on October 7, 2023. Or that we would find ourselves living next door to savage terrorists bent on our annihilation. But as Gwyn Morgan points out, it is critical to understand that reality as Israel’s struggle for existence carries on. The history of Israel is nothing short of miraculous. As Morgan personally observed on a tour of the world’s only Jewish state, Israelis have with determination and heart built a free, tolerant, prosperous and technologically-advanced democracy while surrounded by enemies. In the face of ruthless attacks by Hamas and the craven behaviour of supposed friends and allies who now lean in favour of the terrorists, Israel has reminded the rest of the world what real courage is.

Dead Wait: Canada’s Fatal Obsession with Public Health Care

Canada spends more on health care than just about any other country in the world, and with abysmal results. Yet when it comes to fixing the problem, most politicians and policy-makers are immune to common sense. As business leader Gwyn Morgan writes, allowing private options alongside government-funded health care has been proven to help patients in both systems – around the world and here in Canada, too. Yet the courts continued to uphold restrictions on private care while the Mark Carney government simply promises to throw still more money at the problem – showing itself to be as deluded and dogmatic as those who went before.

“Owe Canada”: Our Nation’s Looming Fiscal Abyss

For anyone who still bought into Mark Carney’s self-declared image as the great global banker who would responsibly manage Canada’s finances, his recent promise to juice defence spending to 5 percent of GDP – $155 billion per year in today’s dollars – must surely be the final straw. The Liberal Prime Minister had already announced massive spending hikes and a huge deficit, with interest on the federal debt to hit $70 billion by 2029. All this will spell doom for a country already struggling with declining productivity, zero growth and a falling standard of living, concludes Gwyn Morgan. The veteran business leader charts Canada’s path to budgetary disaster and places the blame squarely where it belongs – on Canada’s profligate Prime Minister.