Power of Unions

“Incredible Achievement of Incompetence”: How the Liberals’ Capitulation to PSAC will Widen the Public-Private Wage Gap

Gwyn Morgan
May 6, 2023
Canadians, we are often told, are a caring and sharing people. Perhaps Canada’s federal workers and their union bosses failed to read the memo, for their recent behaviour has been the opposite: callous and greedy. After coasting through the pandemic “working from home” on full salary, Canada’s “public servants” threw tantrums over returning to the office, demanded an enormous pay increase – then went on strike and blockaded federal facilities. This week they came out of the process richer and even more coddled. Gwyn Morgan charts the federal government’s cave-in to its unionized employees and the ever-growing disparity in compensation between them and the private-sector workers who are taxed to pay for it all. Part II of a special series (Part I is here).
Power of Unions

“Incredible Achievement of Incompetence”: How the Liberals’ Capitulation to PSAC will Widen the Public-Private Wage Gap

Gwyn Morgan
May 6, 2023
Canadians, we are often told, are a caring and sharing people. Perhaps Canada’s federal workers and their union bosses failed to read the memo, for their recent behaviour has been the opposite: callous and greedy. After coasting through the pandemic “working from home” on full salary, Canada’s “public servants” threw tantrums over returning to the office, demanded an enormous pay increase – then went on strike and blockaded federal facilities. This week they came out of the process richer and even more coddled. Gwyn Morgan charts the federal government’s cave-in to its unionized employees and the ever-growing disparity in compensation between them and the private-sector workers who are taxed to pay for it all. Part II of a special series (Part I is here).
Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter

After more than two weeks of shutting down most federal government services, 120,000 of the striking Public Service Alliance of Canada (PSAC) workers falling under the ambit of the federal Treasury Board returned to work on Monday, followed on Thursday by another 39,000 Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) employees. The dual walkouts had been brewing since last spring, when PSAC president Chris Aylward declared: “The government can’t expect workers who have been getting us through the pandemic to shoulder the costs of Canada’s recovery.”

Shoulder the costs of Canada’s recovery? Aylward’s PSAC members not only were paid their full salaries during the pandemic – with most of them allowed to work from home – but also thereby added two more years to their generous pension benefits. After the pandemic faded, many of them bitterly resisted returning to the workplace. What about all the private-sector workers who either lost their jobs entirely or were forced to work part-time for lower wages and fewer or no benefits?

xInversion of reality: Public Service Alliance of Canada president Chris Aylward (left) said unionized civil servants should not “shoulder the costs of Canada’s recovery” following Covid-19; in fact, the public sector grew massively in size and total compensation during the pandemic. Shown at right, PSAC members picketing in Kingston, Ontario, April 19, 2023. (Sources of photos: (left) The Canadian Press/Justin Tang; (right) The Canadian Press/Lars Hagberg)

This Statistics Canada Labour Force Survey shows that in the two-year pandemic period through February 2022, total employment nationwide ended up virtually flat. In January 2022, all of the country’s 206,000 job losses that month were private-sector workers. Meanwhile, public-sector employment has increased by 305,000. Aylward’s statement is worse than fiction; it’s an inversion of reality.

The most rapid growth in public-sector employment was at the federal level. Government of Canada data indicate the federal public service now employs more than 336,000 people. As Jack Mintz, President’s Fellow at the University of Calgary’s School of Public Policy and former president of the C.D. Howe Institute, wrote in the Financial Post in January, annual compensation of federal employees has risen from $38 billion to $58 billion since the Justin Trudeau government gained office in 2015 – a 52 percent increase that far exceeds the growth in the number of federal employees. And still these workers and their unions want even more.

A study by the Fraser Institute using data for the pandemic year 2021 found that government-sector workers enjoyed a 5.5 percent wage premium over private-sector workers even after controlling for differences in age, gender, education, work type/experience, unionization and other labour market factors. Just two years later, the study’s most recent edition finds, the disparity had jumped to 8.5 percent. That was before this week’s deals.

xNot only is the average federal employee much better paid than private-sector workers – including skilled trades in the oil and natural gas sector – but generous pensions, longer vacations and ironclad job security make the disparity even greater. (Source of photos: Shutterstock)

Mintz’s own calculations based on Statistics Canada data suggest that the average full-time federal employee makes $75 per hour – nearly $150,000 per year – in wages and benefits. “That is unbelievable,” Mintz said in a recent interview with C2C. By contrast, he notes, “Oil and gas workers and mining workers, manufacturing workers, make an average $40 per hour.”

The public/private disparity in job-related benefits is much larger than the mere wage difference. More than 86 percent of government workers are covered by a registered pension plan compared with just 23 percent of private-sector workers. Government workers are much less likely to lose their jobs. They have longer paid vacations and take an average of five more days off per year for “personal reasons” than private-sector workers. Moreover, they typically retire more than two years earlier, most likely thanks to their generous pensions.

PSAC was determined to increase that public/private compensation disparity by wresting wage increases of 4.5 percent in each of the next three years. Even that wasn’t enough for the CRA workers, who demanded 20.5 percent more over three years – plus a “one-time adjustment” of another 8 percent, for a total of over 30 percent. Presumably this enormous increase, aptly described as “unprecedented” and “crazy,” was intended to compensate them for “taxing” their brains pushing the keys on an almost fully automated tax return system.

No wonder Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre observed during a recent Question Period that, “It’s one thing to increase the size and cost of the public service…and another thing to be faced with a massive strike by public servants…but it is an especially incredible achievement of incompetence to do both of those at the same time.”

xThe agreement PSAC negotiated for 120,000 Treasury Board workers early this week was not only higher than the federal government originally offered but also higher than the Public Interest Commission recommended. (Source of graph and table: psacunion.ca)

PSAC’s excessive demands would normally be tempered by the possibility of back-to-work legislation – most recently used in 2021 – but the NDP’s support of PSAC’s goals reduced the chances of that to virtually nil. Passing back-to-work legislation with the support of Poilievre’s Conservatives, though technically feasible, was unthinkable for it would have ended the Liberals’ de facto coalition deal with the NDP. That put the Trudeau government between the proverbial rock and a hard place: either leave government services that people count on shut down or agree to a settlement that adds many more billions to already perilously high deficit spending.

In the end, the union’s demands were met for the 120,000 Treasury Board workers, but dressed up in slightly different clothes. Rather than receiving the demanded 13.5 percent increase over three years, PSAC “settled” for a nominal 11.5 percent over four years, but retroactive to 2021 and with a 0.5 percent special adjustment added for 2023. The union’s website shows a total wage increase of 12.6 percent compounded, with 10.1 percent coming immediately. This is not only higher than what the federal government originally offered but higher than the Public Interest Commission recommended.

xPSAC workers will also get a $2,500 lump-sum payment, protection against contracting out and payment to attend “training” in diversity, equity and inclusion – a radical left-wing ideology – while Indigenous federal employees will get paid time off to go hunting. (Source of top photo: The Canadian Press/Lars Hagberg)

That’s not all. According to the union’s triumphant press release issued on Monday, PSAC members will also receive a “pensionable $2,500 one-time lump sum payment that represents an additional 3.7 percent of salary for the average PSAC member.” Moreover, the union also gained new protection against contracting-out with a provision designed to “protect public service jobs and reduce contracting out in the federal public service.” Federal workers will also be paid to attend “training” in diversity, equity and inclusion, i.e., radical left-wing ideology. And Indigenous federal employees will get paid time off to go hunting. It’s true – PSAC is bragging about all of it. On Thursday, the CRA workers tentatively settled for the same deal, considerably less than their original demand, but still a large increase.

It’s hard to comprehend how the settlement could have been worse, both for taxpayers and in how it increases the already-dangerous disparity between public and private-sector workers. As government workers try to justify their excessive wage demands, the rest struggle with the rising cost of groceries and other necessities. These are the same private-sector workers whose taxes pay the cost of the public service. But it has become quite clear that PSAC workers and union bosses just don’t care. This is a shamefully selfish attitude that tears at the fabric of our nation.

The worst may be yet to come. A Government of Canada website lists 32 further federal and provincial union contracts due to expire in 2023, covering a total of 99,000 workers. Those unions have been waiting for the PSAC settlement to set the benchmark. One can be sure they’re delighted with the outcome. The result is certain not only to expand the damagingly disparate compensation of public- and private-sector workers but also accelerate the very inflation the unions claim justify their rich wage demands.

This is a dangerous time for our country. We have a federal government that sinks the nation further and further into debt with profligate spending while deliberately hobbling the resource industries that provide much of Canada’s GDP and export revenue. The government is kept in power by a deeply socialist opposition party whose sole agenda is to blackmail the minority Liberals into expanding social welfare programs that are already unaffordable. And now we have clear evidence that members of our largest public-sector union just don’t care about the fellow Canadians who pay their wages. Our prime minister talks constantly about environmental sustainability. The real question is the social and economic sustainability of the course he has plotted for our beleaguered nation.

Gwyn Morgan is a retired business leader who has been a director of five global corporations.

Source of main image: The Canadian Press/Ryan Remiorz.

Love C2C Journal? Here's how you can help us grow.

More for you

Ottawa is Playing a Game of Charter Chicken with the Provinces

The federal government has long objected to provinces using the Charter of Rights and Freedoms’ “notwithstanding” clause, arguing it lets them trample over the rights of Canadians. But that view, flawed as it is, is nothing compared to Ottawa’s latest gambit on this issue, writes Andrew Roman. Liberal Justice Minister Sean Fraser’s recent intervention in the case of Quebec’s Bill 21 asks the Supreme Court of Canada to declare limits on the use of the notwithstanding clause. This would amount to a backdoor amendment of the Constitution by the court, one that would give judges even more power and leave elected representatives even less scope to avoid or undo their harmful decisions. More than just an attack on provincial autonomy, writes Roman, it threatens to upset the balance at the heart of Canada’s federal democracy.

What if October 7 Had Happened Not in Israel but in Canada?

It is probably beyond the imagination of most Canadians that they would ever face the kind of evil atrocity Israelis suffered on October 7, 2023. Or that we would find ourselves living next door to savage terrorists bent on our annihilation. But as Gwyn Morgan points out, it is critical to understand that reality as Israel’s struggle for existence carries on. The history of Israel is nothing short of miraculous. As Morgan personally observed on a tour of the world’s only Jewish state, Israelis have with determination and heart built a free, tolerant, prosperous and technologically-advanced democracy while surrounded by enemies. In the face of ruthless attacks by Hamas and the craven behaviour of supposed friends and allies who now lean in favour of the terrorists, Israel has reminded the rest of the world what real courage is.

One Country, Two Markets: The Shaky Promise and Unfair Burden of “Decarbonized” Oil

“Decarbonized” oil is being touted as a way to bridge the policy chasm separating energy-rich Alberta and the climate-change-obsessed Mark Carney government. Take the carbon dioxide normally emitted during the production and processing of crude oil and store it underground, the thinking goes, and Canada can have it all: plentiful jobs, a thriving industry, burgeoning exports and falling greenhouse gas emissions. But is “decarbonized” oil really a potential panacea – or an oxymoron that makes no more sense than “dehydrated” water? In this original analysis, former National Energy Board member Ron Wallace evaluates whether a massive push for carbon capture and storage can transform Alberta into a “clean energy superpower” – or will merely saddle its industry and government with a technical boondoggle and unbearable costs while Eastern Canada’s refiners remain free to import dirty oil from abroad.

More from this author

What if October 7 Had Happened Not in Israel but in Canada?

It is probably beyond the imagination of most Canadians that they would ever face the kind of evil atrocity Israelis suffered on October 7, 2023. Or that we would find ourselves living next door to savage terrorists bent on our annihilation. But as Gwyn Morgan points out, it is critical to understand that reality as Israel’s struggle for existence carries on. The history of Israel is nothing short of miraculous. As Morgan personally observed on a tour of the world’s only Jewish state, Israelis have with determination and heart built a free, tolerant, prosperous and technologically-advanced democracy while surrounded by enemies. In the face of ruthless attacks by Hamas and the craven behaviour of supposed friends and allies who now lean in favour of the terrorists, Israel has reminded the rest of the world what real courage is.

Dead Wait: Canada’s Fatal Obsession with Public Health Care

Canada spends more on health care than just about any other country in the world, and with abysmal results. Yet when it comes to fixing the problem, most politicians and policy-makers are immune to common sense. As business leader Gwyn Morgan writes, allowing private options alongside government-funded health care has been proven to help patients in both systems – around the world and here in Canada, too. Yet the courts continued to uphold restrictions on private care while the Mark Carney government simply promises to throw still more money at the problem – showing itself to be as deluded and dogmatic as those who went before.

“Owe Canada”: Our Nation’s Looming Fiscal Abyss

For anyone who still bought into Mark Carney’s self-declared image as the great global banker who would responsibly manage Canada’s finances, his recent promise to juice defence spending to 5 percent of GDP – $155 billion per year in today’s dollars – must surely be the final straw. The Liberal Prime Minister had already announced massive spending hikes and a huge deficit, with interest on the federal debt to hit $70 billion by 2029. All this will spell doom for a country already struggling with declining productivity, zero growth and a falling standard of living, concludes Gwyn Morgan. The veteran business leader charts Canada’s path to budgetary disaster and places the blame squarely where it belongs – on Canada’s profligate Prime Minister.