Diplomacy and Development

Stronger Alliances with First Nations Could Help Overcome Blockade Disruptions

Gwyn Morgan
March 4, 2020
The sight of Justin Trudeau’s ministers genuflecting before petty aristocrats, anarchists, tire-burners and masked thugs sickened millions of Canadians – and made some of us think about hoarding critical supplies. Aside from the venality and sheer ineffectiveness of the Liberals’ approach, Gwyn Morgan was struck by our enlightened rulers’ bone-headed misunderstanding of diplomacy. Going cap-in-hand to the people who despise you is unlikely to end well. And when there are other options, it’s unforgivable. Morgan suggests instead applying age-old principles of diplomacy – like supporting one’s allies to maximize their influence. He should know, for he has done it himself.
Diplomacy and Development

Stronger Alliances with First Nations Could Help Overcome Blockade Disruptions

Gwyn Morgan
March 4, 2020
The sight of Justin Trudeau’s ministers genuflecting before petty aristocrats, anarchists, tire-burners and masked thugs sickened millions of Canadians – and made some of us think about hoarding critical supplies. Aside from the venality and sheer ineffectiveness of the Liberals’ approach, Gwyn Morgan was struck by our enlightened rulers’ bone-headed misunderstanding of diplomacy. Going cap-in-hand to the people who despise you is unlikely to end well. And when there are other options, it’s unforgivable. Morgan suggests instead applying age-old principles of diplomacy – like supporting one’s allies to maximize their influence. He should know, for he has done it himself.
Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter

The year was 2015. We had gathered in the meeting house of the remote Tl’azt’en First Nation at Tache, 215 km northwest of Prince George. I was there as volunteer Chair of the B.C. Industry Training Authority (ITA), the organization responsible for funding and facilitating trades training in the province. Accompanying me were the ITA’s CEO, Gary Herman, and other board members who shared a passion for our dual mission of helping young people gain rewarding careers in the certified trades, while also providing the skills that individuals and organizations would need to carry out virtually any public or private project throughout the province.

Gwyn Morgan, Gary Herman and Andy Calitz believe passionately in trades training for young First Nations members.
Gwyn Morgan, Gary Herman and Andy Calitz believe passionately in trades training for young First Nations members.

One of the ITA’s board members was Andy Calitz, a South African engineer who had led LNG projects around the world. Now, Andy was the CEO of LNG Canada, a joint venture by international energy companies to develop Canada’s first large export facility for liquefied natural gas. It was Andy’s leadership and determination that would make the $40 billion venture situated at Kitimat – the largest industrial project in Canadian history – a reality.  

The natural gas supply for this massive project would be transported from landlocked northeast B.C. gas fields through the Coastal GasLink Pipeline. The pipeline’s construction would create opportunities for the Tl’azt’en and other First Nations members along its route to learn a trade that could provide them with satisfying and well-paying, potentially lifelong careers, and help provide prosperity for their communities.

Making history: LNG Canada’s export facility in Kitimat (digital rendering), now under construction, is the largest-ever industrial project in Canada.
Making history: LNG Canada’s export facility in Kitimat (digital rendering), now under construction, is the largest-ever industrial project in Canada.

But we faced a dilemma. Many young people from those remote villages lacked the academic qualifications normally required even to enter trades training. Learning a certified trade such as electrician, welder or heavy equipment mechanic is a four-year process of schooling and work experience. 

After wrestling with our dilemma, the ITA Board decided to create an entirely new certified trade called Construction Craft Worker. Through this program, trainees would receive the foundational knowledge needed to work safely as labourers, from where they could learn the skills needed to move into advanced trades. At the invitation of the Tl’azt’en Chief, Justa Monk, and Councillors, we came to discuss our Construction Craft Worker initiative.

xThe late Tl’azt’en Chief Justa Monk (above) welcomed IAT leaders in the hopes of securing employment for his members.

Chief Justa Monk offered a traditional welcome and I respectfully responded, describing our mission. Then came a memorable feast of bear, beaver, deer, elk and moose, along with fish from the nearby lake. It turned out to be an emotional day for all. The Chief was near tears as he told us that, while they had heard many leaders’ statements from afar aimed at First Nations, we were the first group of leaders to honour his people by travelling to their village. That meant more to the Chief (who has since passed away) and Council than we could have imagined. The many young band members in attendance expressed their hope that working on the pipeline might help them gain the trade qualifications needed to secure employment afterwards. 

Given their remote location, our board knew the Coastal GasLink Pipeline would be their only chance in a generation to achieve that. The arduous process of gaining approval for the LNG project took much longer than expected but finally, five years after our meeting, the gas supply pipeline is under construction. And 20 First Nations along the route have signed agreements that not only offer employment opportunities, but also financial benefits that will help lift their communities out of poverty.

xIllegal rail blockades disrupt industry and kill jobs – including for Indigenous people – across Canada.

Who could have imagined that this long-held dream would turn into a national nightmare due to opposition by unelected “hereditary” Chiefs of just one of those 20 First Nations? And that this single, internal jurisdictional dispute could spawn illegal blockades disrupting railways, roads and international commerce across our entire nation, and even threaten shortages of things all of us need to live, like heating fuel and food? I’m sure most Canadians were as dismayed as I to see ministers of the Crown meekly asking for “permission” to enter an unlawfully occupied site to “dialogue” with a disparate agglomeration of protesters opposed to virtually everything that we value about our country. 

There have been many times over the years when I’ve witnessed people who keep trying to change the behaviour of an impossibly intransigent opponent, rather than going around them to engage supporters. In this case, the way to do that is breathtakingly obvious. There are 20 First Nations who, just like the Tl’azt’en, are counting on the Coastal GasLink to help lift them out of poverty and provide opportunities for their young people to gain employable skills. If I were Prime Minister, my Cabinet ministers would immediately be on their way to each of those 20 First Nations to solicit their help in making sure the pipeline gets built.

Diplomacy that worked: Siksika Blackfoot Chief Crowfoot making a speech during the Treaty 7 negotiations in the 1870s.
Diplomacy that worked: Siksika Blackfoot Chief Crowfoot making a speech during the Treaty 7 negotiations in the 1870s.

My experience in that Tl’azt’en meeting house shows that ministers from our national government coming to meet First Nations on their own ground would be profoundly impactful in encouraging First Nations leaders who actually care about the future of their people to speak out against those who do not.

Gwyn Morgan is the retired founding CEO of Encana Corp.

Love C2C Journal? Here's how you can help us grow.

More for you

The Other Right to Choose: Reversing the Trudeau Immigration Fiasco

Canada’s immigration system was once the envy of the world. Based on the notion that those who get into the country are those who determine its future, the system chose people best able to contribute. Then the Trudeau Liberals blew it up, opening the gates to just about anyone – including literal terrorists – wreaking economic havoc and breaking Canadians’ faith in the value of citizenship. John Weissenberger, who served as chief of staff to the federal immigration minister in Stephen Harper’s Conservative government, has watched it happen with growing dismay, and argues for a return to sanity – centred on the sensible “points” system that served Canada so well for decades.

Suffer the Little Children: The Liberals’ $10-a-Day Childcare Disaster

Waiting lists stretching years. Plummeting quality. Outraged parents. Providers slowly strangled by red tape. The federal Liberals’ vaunted $10-a-day childcare program has proved an expensive disaster. Five years in, Matthew Lau digs into the many problems and inequities this landmark social policy has delivered. Lau finds B.C., which had a three-year head start on the rest of the country and an enthusiastic NDP government leading the way, in the worst straits of all. With an irretrievably flawed system clearly failing Canadian families, Lau argues that Prime Minister Mark Carney should pivot to a fairer, cheaper and more effective alternative.

From the Strait of Hormuz to Cuba, Net Zero is Dying – Mark Carney Needs to Let Go

After decades spent pursuing net-zero dreams at great cost to their economies and social fabric, most of the world’s industrialized nations are waking back up. War with Iran and the threat of tanker blockades have everyone worried about oil and natural gas supplies and clamouring for energy security. Or nearly everyone. Not Mark Carney, though. Canada’s prime minister keeps pushing industrial carbon taxes higher and insists on wasting taxpayers’ money on windmills that make no difference. Gwyn Morgan recalls his own observation of the global warming movement’s original rise, its morphing into the radical “net zero” cult – and its spectacular global disintegration. It is high time, Morgan writes, that Canadians demand Carney also drop his delusions.

More from this author

From the Strait of Hormuz to Cuba, Net Zero is Dying – Mark Carney Needs to Let Go

After decades spent pursuing net-zero dreams at great cost to their economies and social fabric, most of the world’s industrialized nations are waking back up. War with Iran and the threat of tanker blockades have everyone worried about oil and natural gas supplies and clamouring for energy security. Or nearly everyone. Not Mark Carney, though. Canada’s prime minister keeps pushing industrial carbon taxes higher and insists on wasting taxpayers’ money on windmills that make no difference. Gwyn Morgan recalls his own observation of the global warming movement’s original rise, its morphing into the radical “net zero” cult – and its spectacular global disintegration. It is high time, Morgan writes, that Canadians demand Carney also drop his delusions.

Future Tense: Why Gen Z is Right to Feel Betrayed

Older generations often roll their eyes when young people seek to blame them for their woes. But if Canada’s Gen Zers feel betrayed by the Boomers, they are right to do so, argues Gwyn Morgan. Years of irresponsible fiscal and regulatory policies have hamstrung the Canadian economy and left younger generations facing a bleak future of stagnant wages, rising taxes and shrinking opportunities. A former business leader who created more than his share of jobs and prosperity during his long corporate career, Morgan casts a worried eye over the next generation – and offers sympathy for the situation they’re inheriting.

The Price of Foolish Pride: What Germany’s Social and Economic Decline Can Teach Canada

Germany was postwar Europe’s most successful nation – until it was seized by an arrogant leftist ideology that led it down a ruinous path. Its government abandoned safe, zero-emission nuclear power for inefficient wind and solar plus natural gas from Vladmir Putin. It threw open its borders to millions of asylum-seekers with barely a thought to the enormous costs or the difficulties of social integration. Today, at the 11th hour, Germany is at last struggling to turn around its decade of economic decline and social disintegration. In this cautionary tale, Gwyn Morgan sees a profound warning for Canada.