Energy and Food Supply

When Intentions Are All: The Disastrous Consequences of the Green Movement’s Actions

Gwyn Morgan
July 17, 2022
It has been said that in the “progressive” mind, intentions matter far more than practical realities. Passion and commitment drive everything, and utopia shimmers on a distant horizon. Who can be against “saving the plant”? The journey may seem pleasant enough for a while, especially in advanced and basically well-run countries whose systems were built with “design margin,” robust enough to absorb some bad contingencies. But that can only carry a country – or a global economy – so far. Gwyn Morgan lays out the awful humanitarian results when unworkable government policies driven by decades of green ideology are compounded by war and geopolitics.
Energy and Food Supply

When Intentions Are All: The Disastrous Consequences of the Green Movement’s Actions

Gwyn Morgan
July 17, 2022
It has been said that in the “progressive” mind, intentions matter far more than practical realities. Passion and commitment drive everything, and utopia shimmers on a distant horizon. Who can be against “saving the plant”? The journey may seem pleasant enough for a while, especially in advanced and basically well-run countries whose systems were built with “design margin,” robust enough to absorb some bad contingencies. But that can only carry a country – or a global economy – so far. Gwyn Morgan lays out the awful humanitarian results when unworkable government policies driven by decades of green ideology are compounded by war and geopolitics.
Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter

That old adage, “The road to hell is paved with good intentions,” may never be proven truer than regarding the disastrous consequences of the green movement’s crusade to replace the 84 percent of global energy supplied by fossil fuels with windmills, solar panels and biofuels. The focus of public discussion today is largely on the energy supply and prices. But there’s also a more profoundly humanitarian impact. Here is my list of green-motivated actions and consequences.

Energy Supply

Action: Germany decides to replace its nuclear power plants with wind farms and solar arrays, which prove both unaffordable and unreliable, leaving no choice but to import Russian natural gas. Russia invades Ukraine. Germany tries to replace Russian gas with other sources.

As the Russo-Ukrainian war grinds on, European economies are ground down by the worsening energy crisis. Among its effects: natural gas prices rising by 700 percent in Germany and looming gas rationing threaten to force closure of the gigantic BASF integrated chemical facility in Ludwigshafen, with global economic ramifications. It was green policies, however, that made Germany so vulnerable to Russian gas in the first place. (Source of bottom photo: de.kompass.com)

Consequences: Natural gas prices increase by 700 percent, forcing Germany and several other European countries to restart shuttered coal plants. EU economies go into freefall while emissions rise faster than ever.

Action: No fewer than 17 Canadian liquefied natural gas (LNG) projects that, among their other market outlets, could have eliminated the need for Germany to import Russian gas at all were stymied by impossible-to-meet Canadian federal government rules which demanded that the emissions resulting from their construction and operation be “net zero.” The Trudeau Liberals’ delusionary “net zero” target also drives policies that limit exports from the world’s third-largest oil reserves – the Alberta oil sands.

Consequences: Germany faces the Hobson’s choice of continuing to fund Russia’s brutal invasion or face a winter of disastrous energy shortages. Already the creeping scarcity is raising concerns that the world’s largest integrated chemical complex – BASF on the Rhine River in Germany – which has 200 facilities making products and inputs used in nearly everything and without which the world economy can scarcely function, may need to go to 50 percent output or even be closed entirely. The gas situation has also prompted German utilities to announce that residential buildings will only be heated to 17° C at night, raising fears of elderly people falling ill or worse in their apartments come winter.

In addition to holding Europe hostage using its natural gas, Russia also becomes the world crude oil market’s “swing-producer.” Oil prices skyrocket, raising the cost of transportation for industry and individuals. Inflation wreaks havoc around the globe.

Action: China pretends to reduce greenhouse gas emissions while continuing to escalate cheap coal-fired power generation. The inexpensive electricity generated from coal is used by the factories that manufacture the solar panels and wind turbine blades being exported to generate intermittent, costly electricity in Western countries. Green government zealots in those Western countries meanwhile implement policies mandating ever-more wind and solar power generation combined with continually rising carbon taxes.

Consequences: Western manufacturers cannot compete, leaving no choice but importing Chinese goods. China uses the West’s money to produce the weapons systems and infrastructure (like the Belt and Road Initiative) needed for global dominance.

The West’s environmental obsessions are convenient – and highly profitable – for China, which uses cheap electricity generated from coal to make solar panels (top) and wind turbine blades for Western countries, using the profits to finance its relentless geopolitical expansion, including the Belt and Road Initiative (depicted on the map at bottom). (Sources: (photo) South China Morning Post/ Xinhua; (map) asiagreen.com)

So that’s how the green movement has paved the road to energy supply and Chinese dominance hell. But there is a further heart-wrenching result of green ideology.

Global Food Supply

Russian President Vladimir Putin’s Black Sea blockade of Ukrainian wheat, corn and vegetable oil exports is being blamed for the current food shortages gripping more and more countries, with concerns growing in some of outright starvation. But as reprehensible as Putin’s actions are, the green movement’s impact on the world’s food supply is profoundly greater than the Ukrainian export reduction. As with energy supply, many of the actions go back years or beyond a decade, while the consequences on global grain supply are now becoming painful.

Action: Policies are implemented in Europe and North America mandating the blending of ethanol produced from corn into gasoline.

Consequence: A disastrous reduction in global grain supply. The U.S. is the world’s largest corn producer, at 384 million tonnes per year. One-third of that, or 128 million tonnes, is currently allocated to producing ethanol. Other countries convert a combined 137 million tonnes of grain into fuel ethanol, for a total of 265 million tonnes. Ukraine’s pre-war production of all grains combined was 74 million tonnes per year. With biofuel production worldwide consuming more than three times that much, the reality is that the blockade of Ukraine’s ports has merely exacerbated a much larger and avoidable problem created by green policies.

The global food crisis begins here: A staggering 265 million tonnes of corn (left) annually is used not as food but converted into ethanol for use in blended gasoline (right). This and other Western environmental fetishes, not Russia’s blockade of Ukraine’s ports, are the fundamental cause of rising food prices, increasing scarcity and looming starvation in the poorest countries. (Sources of photos: (left) AP Photo/ Stephen Groves; (right) AP Photo/ Rogelio V. Solis, File)

Cereal Grain Production

Action: Carbon taxes drive up the cost of tractor fuel and grain drying. Nitrogen fertilizer prices shoot up because these fertilizers are made from natural gas. Potash-based fertilizer prices rise due to increased mining, processing and transportation costs.

Consequences: Higher prices and reduced supply of cereal grains. Starvation looms in poor, import-dependent countries.

Action: Environmental zealots campaign for governments to ban a product critical to food supply in developing countries. That product is Roundup. Invented decades ago by chemical company Monsanto, Roundup is well-known as a handy weed-killer to have for the yard but, far more importantly, has dramatically improved crop yields for Third World farmers by killing weeds without the need for heavy physical cultivation that depletes soil nutrients and moisture. Along with other elements of the “Green Revolution,” Roundup has helped chronically under-productive, food-importing countries that were always just one bad harvest from starvation to become solidly self-sufficient in food production, or even net exporters.

“Our Farmers, Our Future” (translation of Dutch sign at bottom): The green-driven push for “sustainable” agriculture with organic farming (i.e., banning chemical fertilizers and pesticides) is driving down crop yields and crushing export revenues, upending entire developing economies in South Asia and Africa (top). The push for “Net Zero” threatens the same in Western countries, including Holland (bottom), whose world-class agricultural sector faces mandated reductions in livestock to meet nitrogen emissions targets, triggering nationwide protests like this tractor blockade outside Zaandam, north of Amsterdam. (Sources of photos: (top) agroecologyfund.org; (bottom) AP Photo/Peter Dejong)

From the time of its introduction, green activists have attacked Roundup as an allegedly cancer-causing form of “Franken-science.” But decades of experience and authoritative studies by scientists from several countries have found that, when used with the same care as any other chemical product, the health risks of Roundup are extremely low. In any event, Roundup has extended untold millions of lives by enabling many developing countries to provide a steady diet and a healthy number of calories even to their poor.

Consequence: If Roundup is banned or its use sharply curtailed, the consequence will be to set back food production in numerous developing countries by decades, with predictable results including reduced life expectancy for the poor.

Meat Production

Action: The governments of Spain and the Netherlands announce policies to reduce and eventually phase out the use of livestock, partly to drive down the release of nitrous oxides into the atmosphere. Farmers fear the same actions in other EU countries.

Consequence: Reduced supplies of meat and dairy products. Destruction of the way of life, income and property values of farmers. Socio-political chaos as desperate farmers protest in Madrid and Dutch farmers congest highways and block entrances to food warehouses. Police in Holland actually shoot at a 16-year-old farm boy at the wheel of a tractor – but thankfully miss.

The combined impact of the cereal grains diverted to motor fuel, carbon taxation on grain farmers and government policies to phase out animal husbandry are not only tragic for the embattled farmers themselves but are increasing food costs while reducing supply. No wonder conspiracy theorists believe the green movement’s ultimate goal is to save the planet through depopulation.

It’s time for a reality-based fork in the green movement’s road to hell.

Gwyn Morgan is a retired business leader who has been a director of five global corporations.

Source of main image: Shutterstock.

Love C2C Journal? Here's how you can help us grow.

More for you

One Flew Over the Kangaroo Court, Part II: The System Invents its Own Jurisprudence

An encounter with a nearly incomprehensible, seemingly absurd and coldly indifferent judicial body offering no apparent hope of resolution would surely cause most citizens to give up in disgust. Gleb Lisikh is made of different stuff; being patronized and rebuffed only makes him dig harder. In this continuation of his now three-year-long legal Odyssey (Part I can be read here), Lisikh provides a firsthand account of the worsening dysfunction of Canada’s court system – and makes the startling discovery that activist human rights adjudicators are attempting to exclude millions of Ontarians from the protection of the human rights code.

Conservatism’s Greatest Canadian Teacher: What we can Learn from George Grant

Most everyone would agree the political movement led by Pierre Poilievre is not your parents’ Conservative Party. Then again, neither arguably was the government of Stephen Harper. Did the 50s-era populist John Diefenbaker embody “real” conservatism? For that matter, did Sir John A. Macdonald? One man who spent his life struggling to define Canadian conservatism and determine who measured up – and who fell short – was political philosopher George Grant. For Grant, conservatism was rooted in the pushback against the interconnected forces of liberalism, technology and the American superstate. Now, a group of (mostly young) conservatives have taken up the challenge of evaluating whether Grant himself knew what he was talking about, and how his ideas might be applied today. Barry Cooper examines their work.

Malign Neglect: What Calgary’s Water-Main Break Reveals about the Failure of City Government

The rupture of Calgary’s biggest water main revealed more than the problems of aging infrastructure. It showed a civic bureaucracy unable to provide basic services or fix things when they break, and a mayor eager to blame others and scold citizens for their selfishness in wanting city services in return for their tax dollars. Above all, it laid bare the increasing tendency of governments to neglect their core responsibilities in favour of social policy fetishes, and to sidestep accountability when things go wrong. Clear, competent, mission-focused public servants are a vanishing breed, writes George Koch, and governing a city is now mainly about keeping city workers, senior officials and elected politicians happy.

More from this author

The Pawns Push Back against the Trudeau Government’s Electric Vehicle Diktats

Perhaps there is a certain twisted logic to the woke left’s attempt to convince schoolchildren that math is racist and that 2 plus 2 might well equal 5. For this may be the only way to get the “math” surrounding the Justin Trudeau government’s push to force Canadians into buying only electric vehicles as of 2035 to work in any way at all. Gwyn Morgan reviews the actual math of key elements of the EV transition scheme – the electric power needs, the subsidized purchases, the tax credits, the vast number of required charging stations, the maintenance of roads – and finds both the costs and the implementation obstacles to be a mixture of steep, dubious and prohibitive. So much so, Morgan concludes, as to cast the entire EV transition in doubt.

A Wealth-Creating Way of Reducing Global CO2 Emissions

It is Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s contention there’s no “business case” for exporting Canada’s abundant, inexpensively produced natural gas as LNG. But Canadians might do well to politely decline management consulting advice from a former substitute drama teacher who was born into wealth and has never had to meet a payroll, balance a budget or make a sale. Bluntly stated, someone who has shown no evidence of being able to run the proverbial lemonade stand. And one whose real agenda, the evidence shows, is to strangle the nation’s most productive and wealth-generating industry. With the first LNG ship finally expected to dock at Kitimat, B.C. over the next year and load Canada’s first-ever LNG export cargo, Gwyn Morgan lays out the business and environmental cases for ramping up our LNG exports – and having them count towards Canada’s greenhouse gas reduction targets.

The Worrisome Wave of Politicized Prosecutions

Shaping criminal charges, bail decisions or prison sentences around an accused person’s political or religious beliefs is utterly odious – a hallmark of tinpot tyrannies and totalitarian hellholes. Such practices have no place in any constitutional nation, let alone a mature democracy that presents itself as a model to the world. But that is increasingly the situation in Canada, writes Gwyn Morgan. Comparing the treatment of protesters accused of minor infractions to those of incorrigible criminals who maim and kill, Morgan finds a yawning mismatch that suggests political motivations are increasingly a factor in today’s criminal justice system.

Share This Story

Donate

Subscribe to the C2C Weekly
It's Free!

* indicates required
Interests
By providing your email you consent to receive news and updates from C2C Journal. You may unsubscribe at any time.