Stories
When hunters act like socialists: Rainer Knopff on how hunters killed a free market proposal in Alberta
May 28, 2013
While federal Liberals seem increasingly pro-market, hunters in Alberta killed off a proposal to introduce market forces to hunting. Rainer Knopff explains…
Stories

When hunters act like socialists: Rainer Knopff on how hunters killed a free market proposal in Alberta

May 28, 2013
While federal Liberals seem increasingly pro-market, hunters in Alberta killed off a proposal to introduce market forces to hunting. Rainer Knopff explains…
Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter

Market incentives as tools of public policy have been much in the news lately, especially because prominent Liberals are espousing them. Former Liberal Prime Minister Paul Martin is a strong advocate of “social financing,” through which government encourages private “social entrepreneurs,” including charitable institutions, to design and deliver innovative solutions to such problems as criminal recidivism and homelessness.

During the Liberal Leadership race,candidates Martha Hall Findlay, Marc Garneau, and (eventual winner) Justin Trudeau also supported free markets—at least on some issues. In Andrew Coyne’s words, “Hall Findlay has proposed dismantling the costly system of farm quotas known as supply management. Garneau has taken aim at the domestic telecoms cartel, calling for the market to be opened to foreign competitors. Trudeau has adopted a similarly open-market view of the CNOOC takeover of Nexen, and of foreign investment generally.”

Coyne hints that this Liberal praise of markets is explained in part by the party’s need to gain support among pro-market Western Canadians.

The West loomed especially large for Liberal leadership hopefuls because all ridings were weighted equally in the voting process, so that “voters in western ridings, where Liberals are few on the ground, [had] vastly disproportionate weight.”

But Westerners do not uniformly support market-based policy instruments, not even in Alberta (which my colleague Barry Cooper calls the “west of the West”).

This lesson was driven home to me in 2008 when I was part of a group proposing a market-oriented approach to the rural production of ecological goods and services in Alberta.

We argued that farmers and ranchers, who can charge energy companies for access to the publicly owned mineral resources beneath their lands, should be similarly able to charge some hunters for access to the publicly owned wildlife upon their lands. In jurisdictions that have adopted such policies, wildlife habitat has improved to the general benefit of the environment. The proposal was dubbed “Hunting for Habitat”.

This proposal sought a middle way between complete privatization of hunting and the tradition of “free” hunting for resident “public hunters.” Landowners in experimental pilot projects would have been able to sell a limited portion of available hunting “tags” on the open market, but on the condition that they provided comparable free opportunities to public hunters.

The pilot projects were to test the proposition that Hunting for Habitat incentives would cause some game populations to grow significantly, because farmers and ranchers would have new financial reasons to promote them and their habitat. If targeted game populations grew enough, Alberta’s public hunters would increase their hunting opportunities even though they would no longer get the lion’s share of those opportunities. All of a small pie can be less than a healthy slice of a much larger pie.

Regrettably, Alberta’s organized hunting community effectively shot down this policy.

Hunters opposed the Hunting for Habitat middle ground for the same reason that Friends of Medicare opposed former Alberta Premier Ralph Klein’s “third way” between Canada’s extensively public health care system and the more heavily privatized American alternative. Friends of Medicare saw any move away from public health care as the first step onto a slippery slope to complete privatization. Alberta hunters discerned in Hunting for Habitat a similar slippery slope to the extensively privatized hunting found in jurisdictions like Texas.

Not all slopes are slippery, however, and stable middle-ground positions exist in both health care and hunting policy. Health care policy in most advanced democracies provided the model for Klein’s “third way,” and several jurisdictions (including such American states as Utah) have established similarly stable balances between private incentives and free
public access in hunting policy.

As valuable as market-based policy instruments can be, the opposition to them is predictable and powerful. Even in such apparently favourable contexts as Alberta, the modest use of market incentives in middle-ground policies can go down to defeat. Cormack Gates and I tell the story of the rise and fall of Hunting for Habitat at length in a recent study published by the Frontier Centre.

The famed ecologist Aldo Leopold long ago wrote that “conservation will ultimately boil down to rewarding the private landowner who conserves the public interest,” and that in the case of wildlife this means compensating private landowners “directly or indirectly for producing a wildlife crop and for the privilege of harvesting it.”

Hunting for Habitat failed to implement Leopold’s prescription. No doubt there is a better way. Might the growing cross-party interest in market based policy instruments help us find it?

~

Rainer Knopff is a professor in the Department of Political Science and the School of Public Policy at the University of Calgary

Love C2C Journal? Here's how you can help us grow.

More for you

The Missing Apprentice: What AI in the Workplace Means for Canada’s Companies

Last week’s announcement that Microsoft will shed a stunning 27 percent of its global workforce seems to confirm popular fears that AI will soon devour virtually every white-collar job on the planet. While such anxiety isn’t entirely baseless, writes Gleb Tsipursky, the evidence so far suggests it is exaggerated. The greater risk, Tsipursky argues, lies in AI’s irresistible allure persuading companies to narrow their incoming “talent pipeline” so much they starve themselves of their own future expertise – the long-serving people who can exercise sound judgment and fix problems. Avoiding such a slow-motion economic apocalypse, Tsipursky advises, will depend on Canadian employers leveraging AI’s impressive productivity-enhancing powers to maintain a hiring flow of novices sufficient to mature into tomorrow’s seasoned hands.

Absent Minded: Ontario Tackles the School Attendance Crisis

Canadian schools have a problem – kids aren’t showing up. In Ontario, nearly 60 percent of high school students aren’t meeting the provincial standard for attendance. And Canada leads the world in absenteeism among children of university-educated parents. Yet when Ontario’s education minister announced he was getting tough on truancy, he was hammered from all sides, including “progressive” academics, conservative education reformers, sports parents and, of course, always-angry teachers’ unions. Christina Park looks into the causes of absenteeism and compares Ontario’s reforms to what various other countries are also trying to do about it. As Park explains, nothing can be fixed in Canada’s chaotic school systems until students start showing up for class.

Continental Grift: Why the Liberal Government’s Fixation with Europe Is a Sham

Market diversification is a sensible enough strategy for Canada, but Mark Carney’s fixation on closer ties with Europe is anything but. For one thing, argues business veteran Gwyn Morgan, we’ve already got comprehensive free trade deals with virtually all of Europe. Cozying up further to a dysfunctional, declining EU is pure folly. Far better for the Carney government to focus on Canada’s own self-inflicted economic problems – inflation, taxes, public debt, the disastrous drought in foreign investment. Oh, and the ongoing lack of free trade within our own borders. No need for overseas adventures, notes Morgan; there’s plenty of work to be done at home.

More from this author

Can Canada work through its legal challenges and finally free the beer?

Why Killing the IILA Didn’t Free the Beer

As you take that satisfying summertime pull of the frothy, feel crisp cool wine on your lips or perk up to the sound of ice cubes rattling, you might pause to consider just how much your adult beverage has endured to find its way into your possession. Provincial liquor control monopolies, in particular, limit the acquisition and jack up the prices of “imported” beverages – even those produced in the next province. Hopes ran high that the most recent round of legal jousting and political fine-tuning would throw things wide open. Constitutional law expert and connoisseur of fermentation and distillation Rainer Knopff explains why, sadly, killing the IILA didn’t free the beer.

How love and Plato transformed my life

During a backpacking tour of Europe in 1971-72, Rainer Knopff very nearly missed the train carrying his personal and political destinies. Things might have turned out very differently for the future political scientist and member of the “Calgary School” of conservative academics if the train had not returned to the station, thereby reuniting him with the woman he would marry and his (then unread) copy of Plato’s Republic.

Charter Hyperbole: The New Politics of Heresy

Law, especially rights-entrenching constitutional law, has become a new sacred text, allegedly defining the legitimate community and putting apostates beyond its pale. In Canada, the pulpit hyperbole that cast Wilfrid Laurier as a heretic in late 19th Century Quebec has been replaced by the “Charter Hyperbole” now used to demonize Stephen Harper.