Stories

Canada’s Trumpian tipping point

Peter Shawn Taylor
February 28, 2018
If the oilsands stay in the ground and pipelines and LNG terminals don’t get built, and governments continue to suffocate other natural resource and infrastructure development with excessive taxation and regulation, a lot of Canadians could wind up like the unemployed masses in the U.S. Rust Belt states – and mad enough to vote for a populist demagogue promising to make their lives great again. We’re not there yet, writes Peter Shawn Taylor, but the current rout of capital from Canada’s oilsands represents foreclosure on thousands of high-paying blue collar jobs and raises the risk of a Trumpian political backlash.
Stories

Canada’s Trumpian tipping point

Peter Shawn Taylor
February 28, 2018
If the oilsands stay in the ground and pipelines and LNG terminals don’t get built, and governments continue to suffocate other natural resource and infrastructure development with excessive taxation and regulation, a lot of Canadians could wind up like the unemployed masses in the U.S. Rust Belt states – and mad enough to vote for a populist demagogue promising to make their lives great again. We’re not there yet, writes Peter Shawn Taylor, but the current rout of capital from Canada’s oilsands represents foreclosure on thousands of high-paying blue collar jobs and raises the risk of a Trumpian political backlash.
Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter

Attention environmentalists and assorted politicians eager to shut down Canada’s oilsands: be careful what you wish for. You could be creating the conditions necessary for a Canadian Donald Trump. How’s that for an unintended consequence?

As has been frequently observed, countries around the world have been moving away from the post-war ideals of free trade, open borders and international co-operation and towards a greater focus on national sovereignty and economic populism. Aside from Trump’s chaotic presidency, this trend can be seen in the Brexit vote, as well as the recent success of anti-establishment parties throughout Europe.

Canada, thankfully, offers no evidence of such a shift. For now. All major political parties support immigration – the debate generally centres around appropriate border control – and free trade also enjoys broad public approval. How have we avoided this outbreak of Canada First populism? It’s not because we’re special. It’s because we’ve benefited from wise policy and some very special conditions.

To understand how and why Canada has avoided the politics of exclusion, it’s necessary to unpack what drives it in other countries. Populism is, in general, a symptom of deep concern about economic security, particularly among those most affected by the changes of the 21st century economy. This was particularly true in Trump’s victory. In the key Rust Belt states of Wisconsin, Michigan and Pennsylvania, for example, he won over worried voters by promising to protect manufacturing jobs and defend the country’s borders from illegal immigrants.

Well-paying factory jobs were once the means by which American males without a college education climbed the ladder to success. But the rise of China, increasing automation and a host of other factors have put a roadblock on this path to prosperity – opening the door for Trump’s anti-trade, America First rhetoric. When a significant and vocal segment of voters feel they’re falling behind and have no route to success, we shouldn’t be surprised that they gravitate to politicians who speak to their interests.

In Canada, manufacturing has never been as important to social mobility as it is in the United States. Rather, we have relied on the housing and natural resources sectors to keep economic anxiety at bay. Both offer a steady supply of blue collar jobs for workers from across the country who do not have university education.

Consider Alberta’s oilsands. Between 2002 and 2012, the oilsands received $100-billion in private sector investment. Aside from the obvious employment benefits this provided to Albertans, the Conference Board of Canada calculates that every $1-billion in investment generates an estimated 1,200 person years of employment outside the province. Workers from Newfoundland & Labrador, for example, were often the biggest beneficiaries of Alberta’s insatiable demand for labour, surpassing even neighbouring Saskatchewan and British Columbia in terms of jobs filled. During the boom years any Canadian prepared to work hard knew they could find a job in the oilsands. And this provides a crucial sense of economic security in all provinces.

Alberta’s jobs juggernaut was obviously derailed by the oil market crash of 2015. Thankfully, a red-hot national housing market stepped up to shoulder the burden. Now, however, with a potential slowdown in new home construction given recent interest rate hikes, the burden has fallen back onto the oil patch. And there’s already modest signs of revival – with the price of oil on the rise Alberta is once again reporting net in-migration as workers make their way back to the province.

This tag-team approach to blue collar economic opportunity deserves recognition as a major factor in keeping a lid on disillusioned voters across Canada. As long as there are jobs readily available in the oilsands or housing sectors, blue collar workers with less than a university education need not fret about their future. And this means populist demagogues can’t gain traction by demonizing free trade or too much immigration. A booming oilsands thus act as a crucial safety valve, protecting Canada from the raw populist politics that have convulsed other countries.

So how do Canada’s urban elites treat its oilsands, given the huge economic, political and social benefits at play? Increasingly with extreme prejudice. The federal government makes it nearly impossible to build new pipelines by changing the rules midstream and creating new and ever-stricter regulatory requirements. Investors face constant demands to divest their oilsands stocks on moral grounds. New carbon taxes put even more strain on the sector. Remember, it is the end game of many environmental activists and politicians to shut down the oilsands.

But oilsands opponents haven’t thought through the ultimate consequences of their desire. Shutting down this economic engine of Canada by killing pipeline projects like Energy East, Northern Gateway, and Trans Mountain, and derailing other energy megaprojects like the Pacific NorthWest LNG terminal, means severing an important path to prosperity for a large segment of Canadians. Take away the promise of economic security and upward mobility that the resources sector provides to blue collar workers and they’re likely to become rather resentful. And open to new political voices.

A Canada without an oilsands – and the steady supply of high paying, blue collar jobs it provides – is a Canada susceptible to the siren call of populist politicians. Anyone who thinks Canada is a special country because it has so far avoided the politics of exclusion, should be mindful of what is necessary to keep it that way.

Love C2C Journal? Here's how you can help us grow.

More for you

The Housing Market Isn’t Racist. Blame Your Parents Instead

Diversity may be our strength. But it is now alarmingly commonplace in Canada to blame any perceived diversity in outcomes between racial groups on vaguely-defined “systemic racism” or “white supremacy”. Case in point: the Federal Housing Advocate’s allegations of rampant racism in Canada’s housing market, and the need to address it with outlandishly disruptive policies. Delving deep into Statistics Canada’s ample supply of race-based data, Peter Shawn Taylor considers the evidence for racism in Canadian housing, education, income and poverty statistics, and finds a more convincing explanation much closer to home.

Young Offenders: Meet the Angry Socialists Poisoning Our Politics

Social media is widely blamed for poisoning the public conversation on a range of topics – especially politics and contentious social questions. But there’s a possibly even more dangerous force growing on the internet: an online community of YouTubers and livestreamers spouting far-left dogma, praising political violence and denigrating their opponents as evil, far-right fascists. Using fallacious arguments, psychological manipulation and overheated rhetoric, they seek to radicalize young people and convert them to their cause. Millions are tuning in, and mainstream “progressive” politicians are jumping on their bandwagons. Noah Jarvis profiles three of these socialist crusaders and explains why they are such a threat.

The Worrisome Wave of Politicized Prosecutions

Shaping criminal charges, bail decisions or prison sentences around an accused person’s political or religious beliefs is utterly odious – a hallmark of tinpot tyrannies and totalitarian hellholes. Such practices have no place in any constitutional nation, let alone a mature democracy that presents itself as a model to the world. But that is increasingly the situation in Canada, writes Gwyn Morgan. Comparing the treatment of protesters accused of minor infractions to those of incorrigible criminals who maim and kill, Morgan finds a yawning mismatch that suggests political motivations are increasingly a factor in today’s criminal justice system.

More from this author

The Housing Market Isn’t Racist. Blame Your Parents Instead

Diversity may be our strength. But it is now alarmingly commonplace in Canada to blame any perceived diversity in outcomes between racial groups on vaguely-defined “systemic racism” or “white supremacy”. Case in point: the Federal Housing Advocate’s allegations of rampant racism in Canada’s housing market, and the need to address it with outlandishly disruptive policies. Delving deep into Statistics Canada’s ample supply of race-based data, Peter Shawn Taylor considers the evidence for racism in Canadian housing, education, income and poverty statistics, and finds a more convincing explanation much closer to home.

State of Fear: How Obsessive Demands for Police Checks are Destroying the Volunteer Sector

Everyone wants to protect children. Everyone also appreciates the benefits of a robust and engaged volunteer sector. We should be able to have both at the same time. Yet many long-time volunteers are quitting and potential new entrants are skipping the experience altogether. With safety precautions overwhelming the volunteer sector, it is becoming increasingly difficult to give away one’s own labour. Using his personal experience as a guide, Peter Shawn Taylor takes a close look at the charitable sector’s current mania for police checks and other safety measures, the costs they impose on volunteers and whether they’re actually protecting our kids from sexual predators.

Still the Dangerous River: The Nahanni Part II

The South Nahanni River is widely recognized as the Holy Grail of Canada’s wild rivers. Paddlers, hikers and nature lovers all dream of experiencing first-hand the wonders of this fabled river in a national park in the Northwest Territories. But how did it earn such a reputation? In the concluding installment of a series that began with his account of a recent canoe trip through the Nahanni’s famous canyons, Peter Shawn Taylor charts the creation and evolution of the river’s aura as a remote place filled with mystery and adventure. From native myths to early 20th century hysteria about headless prospectors to its stature today as a premier bucket-list item, the Nahanni has carved out a permanent place in our national consciousness. It may be Canada’s greatest brand. Here’s how it happened. Part I can be read here.

Share This Story

Donate

Subscribe to the C2C Weekly
It's Free!

* indicates required
Interests
By providing your email you consent to receive news and updates from C2C Journal. You may unsubscribe at any time.