Stories

Collateral damage of the ‘greenest city’

James R. Coggins
August 24, 2018
The City of Vancouver officially aspires to be “the greenest city in the world”. But if it could see beyond the tip of its upturned nose, it would realize that its transit and land-use policies are dumping its traffic and pollution problems on neighbouring cities and towns in the Fraser Valley. James Coggins, eyewitness to the environmental carnage wreaked by Vancouver’s selfish green virtuousness, reports.
Stories

Collateral damage of the ‘greenest city’

James R. Coggins
August 24, 2018
The City of Vancouver officially aspires to be “the greenest city in the world”. But if it could see beyond the tip of its upturned nose, it would realize that its transit and land-use policies are dumping its traffic and pollution problems on neighbouring cities and towns in the Fraser Valley. James Coggins, eyewitness to the environmental carnage wreaked by Vancouver’s selfish green virtuousness, reports.
Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter

The Trans-Canada Highway runs through the Fraser Valley less than a block from our house, connecting Canada’s primary west coast city, Vancouver, to the rest of the country. During rush hour, or when there’s an accident, we can see the traffic back-ups from our front windows.

Our local newspaper, The Abbotsford News, recently reported that the number of automobile accidents on the 62-kilometre stretch of the highway between Langley and Chilliwack (the municipalities to the east and west of Abbotsford, where I live) has recently doubled, from 540 in 2014 to 1,100 in 2017. That means there are now about three accidents a day. Over that three-year period, the number of accidents causing serious injury doubled from 230 to 470. Overall traffic only increased 2 percent a year, but transport truck traffic increased 70 percent, from 1,003 a day to more than 1,700 a day. Experts blame the increased number of accidents on the increased truck traffic, not necessarily because truckers are bad drivers, but because other drivers don’t leave sufficient stopping and maneuvering space for the big rigs.

The highway is simply not wide enough to handle the increased size and volume of traffic on it. Yet because of British Columbia’s mountainous terrain, the Fraser Valley is the only viable transportation corridor leading to Canada’s major west coast city and port, and the Trans-Canada Highway is the only major highway running through this corridor. For the most part, as it runs through Abbotsford from Chilliwack to Langley, it is only four lanes wide, two in each direction.

Despite this reality, many local politicians in metropolitan Vancouver oppose widening of the highway because they don’t want more traffic funneling into their already congested streets. The City of Vancouver has a goal of becoming “the greenest city in the world.” It wants people to travel by bicycle or by public transit. It is spending millions of dollars expanding bike lanes, and billions more are being spent to expand Skytrain (metropolitan Vancouver’s elevated rail transit system) and bus service.

It sounds like state-of-the-art socially and environmentally conscious urban planning, but there’s a catch: as housing prices soar in metropolitan Vancouver, people have been moving out into the Fraser Valley and commuting to work in the city. The major public transit systems do not extend out into the valley (politicians in Vancouver, Burnaby, and other parts of the greater metropolitan area want transit dollars spent in their cities, not out in the valley), so commuters have little choice but to drive on the highway.

The same issues feed the increase in truck traffic. Land has become too expensive in greater Vancouver, so industry is moving out into the valley. Molson-Coors Canada, for example, is in the process of moving its brewery, the largest in western Canada, from Vancouver to Chilliwack. In its effort to become the “greenest” city and reduce its emissions and carbon footprint, Vancouver is actively encouraging industrial relocation. It is happy that factories are being replaced by condos.

However, the result is that as industry is moving out of Vancouver into the Fraser Valley, it leads to a lot of manufactured goods being trucked back into the city. Furthermore, vast swathes of productive Fraser Valley farmland are being turned into industrial parks and parking lots for transport trucks.

Vancouver might succeed in becoming “the greenest city in the world,” but the world might not end up being any better off. In fact, the ever-growing number of accident victims being scraped off the Trans-Canada pavement in the Fraser Valley are decidedly worse off, thanks in large part to Vancouver’s selfish, holier-than-thou green policy imperatives.

These spring from the same mindset that opposes the Trans Mountain pipeline because the environmental activists of metropolitan Vancouver can’t bear the thought of Alberta oilsands crude flowing under their greenest subdivisions to ocean tankers that will deliver it to global markets. So oil from such environmental shirkers as Russia, Venezuela, and Nigeria will be consumed instead. If Vancouver policymakers really want to “think globally, act locally,” they would realize they can’t save the environment by simply moving pollution to someone else’s jurisdiction.

Love C2C Journal? Here's how you can help us grow.

More for you

The Ultimate Green-Washing: how LEED certification raises construction costs and worsens housing affordability while sidelining genuinely sustainable architecture.

The Ultimate Green-Washing: The False Promise of LEED Certification

Builders, developers and politicians have all avidly pursued LEED certification of major buildings and housing over the past several decades. Meant to be the pinnacle of “green” construction standards, LEED demands not just energy efficiency but the pursuit of many nakedly ideological goals like public transit use and even social equity. And its effects go far beyond virtue signalling and woke positioning. As this investigation by engineer Greg Wilson reveals, not only does LEED certification drive up construction costs and make housing affordability even more problematic, but buildings constructed to display its contradictory desires often consume more energy than traditional ones. Wilson calls for a return to sanity and a true form of sustainability: buildings that work well and will last for centuries.

B’nai Brith Canada and other Jewish groups back Canada’s “anti-hate” laws, including the Combatting Hate Act and Online Harms Act – a bet on state power that Ezra Levant and John Carpay warn will backfire.

Misplaced Faith: Why B’nai Brith Canada and Other Jewish Groups Should Oppose “Anti-hate” Laws

That free speech has been fundamental to Judaism for over 3,000 years is especially admirable considering the innumerable anti-Semitic attacks that uncontrolled public discourse has emboldened over the centuries. The courage it takes to defend that principle in present-day Canada is beginning to fray, however, as prominent Jewish organizations like B’nai Brith Canada are backing Ottawa’s recurring expansion of “anti-hate” laws – most recently with the Combatting Hate Act and Online Harms Act. But such legislative cudgels never work, writes Lynne Cohen in this originally reported essay – and often end up being used to batter their original proponents. Seeking safety behind the power of the state, Cohen argues, is exactly the wrong approach. Free speech can be messy, unpleasant – and very hard to extend to one’s enemies – but the alternative is far worse.

“First One to Shine”: Reflections on My Indian Residential School Experience

If you want to learn the truth about a time and place, it would make sense to ask some of those who were there. In this heartfelt memoir, Elaine Ayoungman Clifton, who was born into the Siksika First Nation near Calgary, tells a story today’s activists don’t want you to hear. Far from an instrument of repression and evil, the Indian Residential School she attended for a decade was warm and welcoming, the teachers caring and conscientious. They instilled in her a love of reading, did not try to crush her language and culture, and did not try to separate her from her large family. “I am grateful for what they taught me and the care, friendship and love they gave to me over many years,” Ayoungman Clifton writes. If Canadians really want to respect the lived experience of all Indigenous people, hers is an authentic voice we should listen to.

More from this author

How British Columbia’s NDP Government Plans to Triple the Provincial Debt
Canada’s Troubled Pacific Province, Part I

B.C.’s election campaign officially kicks off in mid-September, but in some ways it feels like it has been underway all summer. There’s trouble aplenty in what was long regarded as Canada’s Pacific paradise, and B.C.’s partisan landscape is being reshaped almost before our eyes. With that in mind, C2C kicks off a special series on Canada’s troubled Pacific Province with James R. Coggins’ examination of B.C.’s burgeoning public debt, a worrisome development in what was once arguably the nation’s financially best-managed province. Coggins charts B.C.’s journey in barely a decade from balanced budgets and manageable debt to seemingly perpetual deficits and a potential tripling of the provincial debt.

Have You Ever Tried Pulling a Camper with an Electric Truck? The Real Costs and Benefits of Ottawa’s EV Revolution

The Trudeau government recently released its regulatory impact statement – including a cost/benefit analysis – explaining the plan to make Canada an all-electric-vehicle nation by 2035. James R. Coggins takes a deep dive into the document and finds it full of wishful thinking and sloppy logic. It also excludes many of the biggest costs consumers and taxpayers will face in the shift to electric cars and trucks. If the Liberals confronted the real costs and benefit of their policy, they’d have to admit that forcing Canadians to go electric will be as impractical as it is pricey. Those amazing and expensive electric pickup trucks? They won’t get you very far with a load in tow.

The Future with Zero-Emission Electric Vehicles

It’s hard not to like electric vehicles. Or rather, it is becoming hard to express open dislike of them. They’re green, clean, quiet, fast, subsidized – and “free” to operate. And if the Liberal government has its way, EVs will soon be the only cars you can buy. It’s all settled! But perhaps it shouldn’t be. James Coggins parts the curtain of EV virtue-signalling and poses some basic questions that should have been answered by now if Canada is to cruise smoothly into its battery-operated future. Car owners and families, brace yourselves for a severe jolt, for Coggins uncovers a yawning vacuum of answers regarding the very fundamentals of building, financing and powering Canada’s soon-to-proliferate EV fleet.