Energy Politics

Fossil Fuel Follies

Gwyn Morgan
January 29, 2022
Reliable, affordable and plentiful energy has been foundational to prosperity in every successful country, and fossil fuels have fulfilled the vast majority of those needs – and continue to. What’s not to like? But if you believe the world is gripped by a “climate emergency” caused by those very fuels, then virtually anything is justifiable to get rid of them. But if, in fact, there are no viable replacements, the results are grotesque performative pantomimes of actual serious energy policies: the “net zero” movement. It aims to defeat and negate not only economics, engineering and common sense but the laws of physics themselves. Gwyn Morgan reviews this world-touring theatre of the absurd and finds there’s no vaccine strong enough to inoculate against global dysfunction.
Energy Politics

Fossil Fuel Follies

Gwyn Morgan
January 29, 2022
Reliable, affordable and plentiful energy has been foundational to prosperity in every successful country, and fossil fuels have fulfilled the vast majority of those needs – and continue to. What’s not to like? But if you believe the world is gripped by a “climate emergency” caused by those very fuels, then virtually anything is justifiable to get rid of them. But if, in fact, there are no viable replacements, the results are grotesque performative pantomimes of actual serious energy policies: the “net zero” movement. It aims to defeat and negate not only economics, engineering and common sense but the laws of physics themselves. Gwyn Morgan reviews this world-touring theatre of the absurd and finds there’s no vaccine strong enough to inoculate against global dysfunction.
Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter

Last year saw an intensification of the great march to “net zero,” aimed at replacing the 84 percent of global energy supplied by fossil fuels. The pursuit of this unrealistic objective featured actions ranging from the impractical to the hypocritical to the simply bizarre. It would be impossible to attend in person every performance of this global romp of political theatre, so here instead is my condensed list of what I’ll call the Fossil Fuel Follies.

xThe bizarre and the hypocritical: A recent “art installation” shrouded Paris’s famous Arc de Triomphe (top) in plastic – a substance France wants to ban. Norway’s huge Johan Sverdrup oilfield (bottom) will produce 720,000 barrels per day and generate more than US$100 billion in export revenue – even as Norway’s government demands all its citizens drive electric cars. (Sources of photos: (top) Delmarty J/ANDBZ/ABACAPRESS, (bottom) Ole Jørgen Bratland)

The Bizarre – The City of Paris celebrated a “monumental” new artwork that consisted of shrouding the massive Arc de Triomphe in a silver and blue fabric. Turns out that fabric is plastic, a product the French government is aiming to ban. And plastic is made from petroleum that France wants phased out to achieve “net zero.”

Energy Ignorance – New York City has decided to combat global warming by replacing natural gas with electricity to heat new buildings. But half of New York’s electricity is generated by natural gas and other fossil fuels. As electricity consumption rises to heat those new buildings, the natural gas “saved” on heat will be burned to generate electricity.

Scandinavian Hypocrisy – Norway has mandated that all new cars sold by 2025 must be electric. Meanwhile, the country produces 4 million barrels of oil per day and is developing new fields to increase production. The export of crude oil is also the main reason Norwegians are prosperous enough to afford EVs.

The Hydrogen Charade – This Globe and Mail article published last August called hydrogen “the most abundant element in the universe.” That’s true about the universe, where hydrogen fuels stars including our sun. But usable hydrogen does not naturally exist on our planet Earth. Usable hydrogen is manufactured in refineries fuelled by natural gas and coal. Hydrogen industry advocates try to counter this by pointing to electrolysis of water using wind and solar power to generate the electricity. This is an impractical and extremely costly approach to creating something that’s supposedly abundant.

Caisse de Depot’s Greenwashing – Quebec’s provincial pension fund says it will divest of oil production assets by the end of the year. No mention of divesting assets that require oil to function, including airports, highways and marine shipping terminals.

Cryptocurrency’s Overlooked Environmental Impact – The Bank of Canada last year increased its work on the feasibility of adopting a digital currency. But there’s no mention of examining the environmental impact of cryptocurrency. Most cryptocurrencies utilize the ultra-complex block-chain technology. Minting new units such as Bitcoin, the first and still the leading cryptocurrency, requires a highly energy-intensive process called “mining.” The electrical power required to mine a single transaction generates an average carbon footprint equivalent to processing over 2 million VISA transactions. Bitcoin as a whole was using more electricity last year than the entire country of Finland. At least one crypto mining outfit has actually purchased a decommissioned coal-fired power plant to generate electricity to run its computers.

xThe real costs of going green: Coal-fired power plant in Pennsylvania (left) purchased by Stronghold Digital Mining to power 1,800 computers for Bitcoin processing; the Nord Stream 2 Pipeline (right) will supply Russian natural gas to its emerging energy hostage, Germany, whose wind-and-solar crusade has flopped. (Source of left photo: Stronghold)

Germany’s Journey from Self-sufficiency to Russian Energy Hostage – Last year saw the culmination of Germany’s 11-year-long process of shutting down its zero-emission nuclear power plants. That incomprehensible decision was based on a plan to replace the lost power with wind and solar which, predictably, proved both prohibitively expensive and unreliable. That left no alternative but to import more natural gas from Russia. But those supplies have proven inadequate. The ostensible solution is still more Russian gas through a new pipeline across the Baltic Sea called Nord Stream 2.

Last March, the German government approved the project, but the escalating Ukraine crisis has led to pressure from its NATO allies to cancel that approval. Now, just as freezing temperatures drive German natural gas prices up ten-fold, Russia has reduced deliveries. Earlier this month, International Energy Agency Executive Director Fatih Barol stated, “I would note that today’s low Russian gas flows coincide with heightened geopolitical tensions over Ukraine.” It’s breathtaking to think both that this geopolitical mess started with the belief that wind and solar could be the answer to any large country’s energy future, and that anyone believed Russia would not exploit its energy supplies as a geopolitical weapon.

xDown the chute: Under COP26, only Western economies are expected to strangle themselves in the rush to “net zero.” In China, India and other developing nations, coal remains king and overall fossil fuel use will soar for decades to come. (Sources of photos: Shutterstock)

Canada Leads COP26 – In the Size of its Delegation – Canada sent 276 delegates to the UN Climate Summit in Glasgow, more than host UK and twice as many as the United States. Among the Prime Minister’s entourage were his own personal videographer, photographer, speechwriter and a 17-person media team made up of press secretaries and communications directors. The number of emissions-intensive private jets required to transport this mega-team was not disclosed. All this ludicrous vanity-driven hype for a country that accounts for less than 2 percent of global emissions.

COP26 Hypocrisy – The main objective of COP26 was to “phase out” coal-fired power. But in the face of opposition from China and India, the world’s two largest coal consumers, the language was changed to “phase down.” China and India currently produce 36 percent of global emissions. Fact-checked data from the Global Coal Plant Tracker shows China has 202 coal-fired power plants under construction or pre-construction, while India has 74 such plants under construction or pre-construction. This trend has no end in sight; Chinese leader Xi recently stated that he will not allow climate change-driven policies to imperil the prosperity of China’s citizenry. The expected life of those coal-using plants is more than 30 years, negating the combined emissions reduction efforts of all other COP26 parties. If Canada were to disappear from the map, India and China’s emissions growth would replace our emissions in less than a year.

The years go by, but global dysfunction remains endemic, spinning off endless variants.

Gwyn Morgan is a retired business leader who has been a director of five global corporations.

Source of main photo: Shutterstock.

Love C2C Journal? Here's how you can help us grow.

More for you

Not Bluffing: Donald Trump and Canada’s Role in the Defence of North America

Donald Trump launched his campaign to strengthen his country’s security with typical bombast. But does the U.S. President’s style entirely delegitimize the substance of his messages? Grave security threats are lapping at North America’s shores. Where others see only chaos and craziness in Trump’s approach, former Canadian Armed Forces officer Barry Sheehy detects coherence and good cause underlying an emerging continental security strategy. And as other countries bend to America’s will, warns Sheehy, Canada had better step up, begin repairing its neglected, decrepit military and national security apparatus, and start doing what it should have done long ago to secure its Far North.

What the Oscar-nominated Canadian Documentary Sugarcane Gets Wrong, and Why

The secret to every good magic trick, Michael Caine’s character explains in the 2006 movie The Prestige, is a willing audience. “You want to be fooled,” he says. Anyone watching the Oscar-nominated documentary film Sugarcane could find themselves slipping into a similar act of self-deception. Focused on a residential school in northern B.C., the Canadian-made Sugarcane withholds key facts, arranges other evidence in confusing ways and encourages viewers – already primed to think the worst of residential schools – to reach unfounded conclusions about what they’re actually seeing. Even professional movie critics have been fooled. Documentary filmmaker Michelle Stirling pulls back the curtain on the dark magic behind Sugarcane.

The Dangerous Absurdity of Canada’s “Nation-to-Nation” Treaty with Manitoba Métis Federation Inc.

When the Métis were included in Canada’s 1982 Constitution as “aboriginal peoples”, some members complained that they’d been handed an “empty box” compared to the ample rights and treaties offered to Indian and Inuit people. Since then, however, Canada’s court system has been hard at work filling up that box. Now, with the signing of a “nation-to-nation” treaty late last year, Manitoba Métis have a box that’s positively overflowing with new rights, powers and federal cash. Peter Best explores how Canada came to recognize a fractious, landless, fully-assimilated, colonial-era group – a group that is actually represented by a corporation – as a nation with an inherent right to self-government, as well as the deeply problematic consequences of this decision.

More from this author

A Mind that Matters: Why Everyone Should Know Thomas Sowell

“It’s hard to imagine a more stupid or dangerous way of making decisions than by putting those decisions in the hands of people who pay no price for being wrong.” Such was Thomas Sowell’s withering critique of bureaucracy – more relevant today than ever. The legendary economist was born to poor sharecroppers and began his career as an avowed Marxist before transforming himself into an insightful and influential critic of the left and all its smug self-regard. In this concise tribute, Gwyn Morgan shares some of Sowell’s sharpest thinking and explains what Canadians can learn from one of America’s greatest minds.

Strike Force: How Powerful Unions like Canada’s Postal Workers Divide Canadians and Damage the Economy

Canada’s beleaguered economy has become beset with strikes called by unions demanding double-digit wage hikes in an era of constrained budgets and slim profit margins. The latest one, by Canada Post, is already inflicting great damage and threatens to drag on, perhaps right up to Christmas. Yet recent legislation passed by the Liberal government (pushed by the NDP) has made it more likely that major strikes will occur, and even more difficult for employers to try to continue functioning. This, writes Gwyn Morgan, is increasingly dividing Canada into a nation of “haves” – overpaid unionized workers – and “have nots” – everyone else. It is time, says Morgan, that someone stood up for the millions of Canadians victimized by power-wielding union bosses and the governments that enable them.

A Frisson of Fission: Why Nuclear Power Won’t Replace Natural Gas as North America’s Critical Fuel

The recent collapse of the power grid in Cuba, plunging the island nation into darkness and grinding its meagre economy to a halt, served as a reminder of electricity’s centrality to modern civilization. That dependency is only expected to increase as more electric vehicles take to the road – and, writes Gwyn Morgan, as the tech sector’s voracious appetite for electrons expands unabated. Morgan pours a pail of cold water on the much-mooted “nuclear revival” that has yet to deliver any actual new electricity. He argues instead that what’s needed is clear-eyed recognition that the most reliable, most abundant, most flexible and most affordable energy source is a fossil fuel located in vast quantities right beneath North Americans’ feet.

Reading Progress

Share This Story by Gwyn Morgan

Donate

Subscribe to the C2C Weekly
It's Free!

* indicates required
Interests
By providing your email you consent to receive news and updates from C2C Journal. You may unsubscribe at any time.