Policy Imitating Art

Giorgio de Chirico and Our Modern-Day Curators of Disaster

David Solway
August 11, 2021
Fascinated by the metaphysics of the city, 20th century Italian artist Giorgio de Chirico produced jarring urban scenes bereft of people and normal human bustle. He meant to trigger contemplation; he didn’t actually hate people. The tiny minds who run our governments, control our public health agencies and staff our hospital system seem to have taken de Chirico’s metaphorical presentations as an operating blueprint, for in David Solway’s view they have delivered a globe-girdling art installation using the world’s cities as their canvas. From soaring commercial vacancy rates and boarded-up businesses in hundreds of the world’s second-tier cities to the moonscape that Manhattan has largely become, Solway denounces the incalculable damage wrought not by SARS-CoV-2 itself – but the government response to it.
Policy Imitating Art

Giorgio de Chirico and Our Modern-Day Curators of Disaster

David Solway
August 11, 2021
Fascinated by the metaphysics of the city, 20th century Italian artist Giorgio de Chirico produced jarring urban scenes bereft of people and normal human bustle. He meant to trigger contemplation; he didn’t actually hate people. The tiny minds who run our governments, control our public health agencies and staff our hospital system seem to have taken de Chirico’s metaphorical presentations as an operating blueprint, for in David Solway’s view they have delivered a globe-girdling art installation using the world’s cities as their canvas. From soaring commercial vacancy rates and boarded-up businesses in hundreds of the world’s second-tier cities to the moonscape that Manhattan has largely become, Solway denounces the incalculable damage wrought not by SARS-CoV-2 itself – but the government response to it.
Share on facebook
Share on Facebook
Share on twitter
Share on Twitter

The city, for all its anonymity, traffic congestion and claustrophobic density, is the centre of the economic and cultural life of a people. What happens to the city happens to the nation and ultimately to the character of its citizens. British philosopher John Gray in his aphoristic tract on humanistic folly Straw Dogs speaks of the grand delusion of stability represented by great cities, especially in the modern era, observing that, “In cities, persons are shadows of places…The settled life they once contained is fading from memory.” Images of our cities today in the wake of draconian Covid-19 regulations and decrees emphasize the point.

Giorgio de Chirico (1888-1978) is considered by many as one of the signature painters of cities in the tradition of Western art, as, for example, Canalleto was famous for his views of Venice and its canals. But the Greece-born Italian’s paintings were not merely representational; in the words of French poet Guillaume Apollinaire, they were best described as a kind of “Metaphysical Painting,” relying on a technique of disorientation to develop a perspective on reality hidden by our habitual preoccupations and assumptions about the world. They intended to enact in paint a revelation of the guileful and enigmatic nature of consensual experience that glazes over the primal strangeness of the world and the natal loneliness of being.

Although he painted himself numerous times, as in the 1925 self-portrait at centre, Giorgio de Chirico’s Pittura Metafisica or “Metaphysical Painting” moved him to produce unsettling cityscapes empty of people and their items of daily life. De Chirico intended to encourage self-reflection – not be taken literally. At right, “The Enigma of an Autumn Afternoon” (1924).

De Chirico’s canvasses “read” like a synthesis of riddle and parable. “One must imagine everything in the world to be a riddle,” he wrote in Memoirs. His imaginary cityscapes, empty plazas, long arcades, brooding figures and sculptural fragments are ways of making us confront what he liked to call, in work after work, the “enigma” underlying everything we see and do, all that normal perception and belief tend to suppress or overlay with facsimiles of “the real.” His intention was to expose the distortions and distractions that consciousness provides for our solace and comfort in a world that neither loves nor needs us.

Horror author and cult figure Thomas Ligotti might well have had de Chirico in mind when he wrote in The Conspiracy against the Human Race that we are invested in immunizing awareness “from any thoughts that are startling and dreadful” in order to perpetuate a “falsifying and specious view of ourselves.” A de Chirico painting repays contemplation for its bizarre motifs and eerie insights into and beneath the surface of the world we take for granted.

But the world of de Chirico’s “phosphorescent” imagination – his word – brings to mind a twisted aspect of presentational immediacy. His spectral cityscapes now suggest the agenda of our political leaders who have led us into a caricature of de Chirico’s art, a travesty which is also worth contemplating, but only as a function of disembrained planning. They are not visionaries but curators of disaster, embodied shadows cast by the totalitarian architecture of deceit and stupidity.

From the city that never sleeps to government-mandated coma: New York City in 2017 (above) and in February 2021 (below) is emblematic of the damage governments have wrought around the world. As a de Chirico curator put it of her own city: “When we walk in Turin today, it is as if we are walking inside a de Chirico. What is a city without people, what is the point of an empty piazza?” (Source of images: Shutterstock)

The destabilization of practical life caused by the official (and generally useless if not counter-productive) response of masks, quarantines, lockdowns, experimental vaccines and endlessly evolving mandates to the Covid-19 panic and variant obsession has turned our cities into ghost conurbations and deep-sixed the economy of nations into the bargain. Some scholars believe it may take a decade to return to the former status quo, others say a generation, Klaus Schwab of the World Economic Forum says “never” (and, we should note, he wants it that way). Schwab may be right.

Certainly, our cities, featuring shuttered shops, half-vacant office towers, phantom skyscrapers, half-deserted lanes and by-ways, and sparsely populated parks, might never quite be the same again – an aura of desolation fortuitously captured in de Chirico’s The Enigma of Skyscrapers. And for those who think I exaggerate, consider just a couple of data points. In the second quarter of this year the city of Calgary’s downtown office vacancy rate hit an all-time record of 29.2 percent and is still climbing, while a large percentage of “occupied” offices are of course barely used. In New York City, for a century the world’s most intensively used downtown, an astonishing 78 percent of office space is still empty of workers. You read that right.

In Metaphysics of Silence: Giorgio De Chirico, Lucio Giuliodori’s summation of the impression left by certain paintings casts a premonitory light on the current practices of our political gauleiters, mired “in the throes of a kind of dehumanizing effect…in a world ruled by madness rather than rationality.” Of course, the Pictor Optimus (as he is known to his admirers) wasn’t thinking of political contingencies, plagues or natural disasters, but of the metaphysical quality of deep perception, of the reality of sadness, menace, dislocation and emptiness beneath the laminate of ordinary life and the consoling illusion of common expectation.

Yet, as art critic Maximiliano Durón has pointed out, our cities under lockdown are weird, serendipitous projections of de Chirico’s strange and unsettling vision. He quotes a colleague, the director of a great art museum in Turin, who writes: “When we walk in Turin today, it is as if we are walking inside a de Chirico. What is a city without people, what is the point of an empty piazza?” The phrase was picked up in a recent video essay by Evan Puschak (aka The Nerdwriter) and could apply to hundreds of cities around the world.

De Chirico’s art is plainly “metaphysical” in Apollonaire’s sense – “meta” is the Greek prefix for “after” or “beyond” – thus beyond the physical. Giuliodori puts it somewhat differently, though to the same effect: “He didn’t set metaphysics beyond physics but rather in physics, deep into the hidden core of it.” The “art” of our political leaders and their medical cronies, however, is anything but metaphysical or even intelligent; it is, frankly, not only misguided but punitive and spiteful, a mutilation of the physical. They succeeded in turning de Chirico’s mysterious mises-en-scène and avowedly melancholic deconstructions of the customary into grim empirical realities, embarking on a program that has not only failed but caused unparalleled devastation.

A synthesis of riddle and parable: De Chirico’s “phosphorescent” imagination might have taught our pandemic managers more about the damage they were about to unleash than swallowing the bogus pandemic projections of Neil Ferguson’s Imperial College Model. Left-to-right: “The Enigma of a Day” (early 1914), “The Skyscraper’s Enigma” (1960), “The Enigma of the Hour” (1911).

The havoc they have released in following the prescriptions of a self-interested medical profession is unprecedented in peacetime, dividing citizens into competing groups of indignation and contempt, wrecking the economic life of entire countries and emptying our city streets and buildings of activity, commerce and pleasure. A visit by our ostensible superiors to the Tate or MoMA or Palazzo Strozzi, where de Chirico’s oeuvre has been on exhibit, would have been far more beneficial than consulting Anthony Fauci or Neil Ferguson, who got almost everything wrong, or relying on their own timorous and mediocre judgment. They have created not a work of imagination but a palpable monstrosity.

One recalls Joseph Conrad’s famous statement of purpose: “My task is…before all, to make you see.” The visions of great artists and writers will often have predictive value, but not always as strict reproductions of the everyday world. They will occasionally assume ironic and unexpected manifestations, semantic fictions or visual exaggerations that become uncannily prescient and part of the sediment of actual existence, like Kafka’s deformed and irrational judicial system in The Trial. In such cases, irrealism tends to become fact and implausibility, truth. Today, making allowance for the distinction between acumen and stupefaction, the painter and the politician, we are indeed walking in a de Chirico.

David Solway’s most recent volume of poetry, The Herb Garden, appeared in 2018 with Guernica Editions. His manifesto, Reflections on Music, Poetry & Politics, was released by Shomron Press in 2016. He has produced two CDs of original songs: Blood Guitar and Other Tales (2014) and Partial to Cain (2019) on which he is accompanied by his pianist wife Janice Fiamengo. His latest book is Notes from a Derelict Culture, Black House Publishing, 2019, London.

Love C2C Journal? Here's how you can help us grow.

More for you

The Long and Honourable History of Vaccines and their Inventors
Part 1 of a Special Series

As the shouting over mandatory Covid-19 vaccination grows louder, as people cement their positions and refuse to budge, as dissenters are vilified, bullied, threatened and forced to get the shot or lose their jobs, and as some in their ranks discredit their cause, we are losing all perspective. Informed decisions – how to vote, what to say in conversation, whether to get vaccinated – require real knowledge. And while the sheer flow of information nowadays is infinite, the truth becomes more opaque and elusive. Welcome to C2C Journal’s special series on vaccines. It is aimed at offering a broad perspective in a calm delivery, in order to inform you and help you preserve your ability to think independently – the basis of individual freedom itself. In Part 1, Lynne Cohen offers an appreciative overview of the struggles to develop some of history’s most important vaccines, and the remarkable individuals who stopped at nothing to get them done.

Childcare on the Ballot

Political theory suggests that freedom and equity are opposing concepts. Allowing greater individual autonomy is assumed to curtail fairness for the less advantaged, and vice versa. Not so when it comes to the 2021 electoral debate over childcare – one of the few areas of sharp contrast between the two main parties. Peter Shawn Taylor takes a close look at the Liberals’ proposed national childcare system and the Conservatives’ refundable childcare tax credit and finds one option delivers not only greater choice for all parents, but superior support for low-income families as well as the promise of new spaces.

The Sins of Our Fathers

The past few months have shown there’s no shortage of people willing to hurl accusations, issue demands and unleash uncontrolled emotions. Such tactics have flooded political life in our age. By contrast, lowering the emotional temperature, proposing a reasonable way out of the mess and driving toward a real resolution are in short supply. In the third and final instalment of C2C’s three-part series on unmarked graves at former Indian Residential Schools (Part 1 can be read here and Part 2 can be read here), Gourav Jaswal examines how other countries have faced the challenge of national reconciliation, then charts a path for Canada to take.

More from this author

A father and son stand hand-in-hand in a field looking up at the sky. Invoking a strong sense of bond felt when one doesn't experience fatherlessness

The Scourge of Fatherlessness and the Death of God

It is almost inarguable that the once-rich and strong tapestry of family life has become seriously frayed, worn and patchy. Divorce is rampant – if marriage occurs at all – and dads have fallen into serious disrepute. Most would agree that it is children who suffer the most as a result. But why did all this happen, and where did it begin? Taking a wide view that ranges from Dostoevsky via Nietzsche to Kate Millett, David Solway traces the crisis centuries back to its spiritual roots as a rebellion against fatherhood – and lays the blame squarely at the feet of modern-day ideologues who seem intent on kicking fatherhood into oblivion.

No Laughing Matter: The March of Killjoy Culture

When the New York Times admonishes the unmistakeably satirical Babylon Bee for spreading “misinformation”, it’s likely a sign that humour is dying – or being killed off. Similarly when the formerly-fearless Bill Maher laments how it’s no longer safe to tell a joke at a party lest one be overheard by a Woke listener and ruined. And even more so when politicians threaten to ban internet memes that lampoon the elites. The eminently serious David Solway reminds us of the essential contribution of humour and laughter to the well-balanced and healthy life – of individual and culture – and points to the civilizational wreckage were levity stamped out. And before it’s too late, suggests we all head out for some subversive “gynecandrical” dancing.

How Climate, Covid-19 and the Great Reset Are Taking Us Back to the Middle Ages

The rise of the educated middle class over the past 250 years is one of the great triumphs of Western civilization. But just as the middle class became ascendant, the intellectual left began figuring out how to tear it back down, an impulse that has since spread to virtually every privileged element in society. The elite’s war on the middle’s prosperity, social mobility and freedom has been accelerating. Where might it take us? Author David Solway is not alone in thinking it won’t end until we are reduced to a new serfdom that, though partially masked by the peons’ access to 21st century gadgetry and other technology, will be very similar in social structure and oppressiveness to the Middle Ages.

Share This Story

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on print

Donate

Subscribe to the C2C Weekly
It's Free!

* indicates required
Interests
By providing your email you consent to receive news and updates from C2C Journal. You may unsubscribe at any time.